Abstract:To increase their conservation value, future non‐lethal nest protection experiments should whenever possible clearly state overall aims, take place over multiple seasons, use a comparable control and test non‐lethal protection methods independently of lethal predator control. Greater focus is required on under‐studied taxa such as cup‐nesting songbirds and birds in South America, Africa and Asia, and novel protection techniques such as deterrents and chemical camouflage. Practitioners should consider the evidence we synthesise here when deciding whether non‐lethal nest protection approaches are optimal for their study system, to increase conservation success and reduce ethical and financial costs. Implementing effective, affordable and ethical conservation management will be crucial for minimising future biodiversity losses. Such management requires reliable foundational evidence to help managers make informed choices about how to address the needs of their target species. Unfortunately, such evidence is still lacking for many species and management scenarios. One major global challenge is improving the reproductive success of threatened species in the context of predation. We conducted a systematic review and meta‐analysis of in situ experiments that used non‐lethal methods to protect bird nests against predators, with the aims of summarising global trends in nest protection efforts, comparing the effectiveness of different protection measures and informing future research and management. We considered peer‐reviewed studies in English. We detected a large geographic and taxonomic bias in the evidence base with 58% of articles conducted in North America and 76% on ground‐nesting birds. Less than 3% of articles involved taxa listed as Endangered or Critically Endangered and 51% of study units lasted just a single breeding season. Nests protected with exclosures, fences and guards were more likely to be successful than their unprotected controls. Interventions involving deterrents, conditioned taste aversion, chemical camouflage and diversionary feeding did not have a significant positive effect on nest success, but the interventions in these categories were less common and more diverse in nature. Synthesis and applications. To increase their conservation value, future non‐lethal nest protection experiments should whenever possible clearly state overall aims, take place over multiple seasons, use a comparable control and test non‐lethal protection methods independently of lethal predator control. Greater focus is required on under‐studied taxa such as cup‐nesting songbirds and birds in South America, Africa and Asia, and novel protection techniques such as deterrents and chemical camouflage. Practitioners should consider the evidence we synthesise here when deciding whether non‐lethal nest protection approaches are optimal for their study system, to increase conservation success and reduce ethical and financial costs.

Ark or park: the need to predict relative effectiveness of ex situ and in situ conservation before attempting captive breeding

Inbreeding and demography interact to impact population recovery from bottlenecks

Current perspectives in avian nutrition: domestic animal models and their role in conservation management

A preliminary global investigation into potential impacts on successful captive breeding for two species of Rhyticeros hornbill

Assessing evolutionary processes over time in a conservation breeding program: a combined approach using molecular data, simulations and pedigree analysis

Can sexual selection theory inform genetic management of captive populations? A review

Evaluation of the Impact of Population Management on the Genetic Parameters of Selected Spiral-Horned Antelopes

Low genetic diversity in the Endangered Crested Ibis Nipponia nippon and implications for conservation

Can We Reestablish a Self-Sustaining Population? A Case Study on Reintroduced Crested Ibis with Population Viability Analysis

Leveraging genomic load estimates to optimize captive breeding programmes

Admixture and reproductive skew shape the conservation value of ex situ populations of the Critically Endangered eastern black rhino

Evaluating the effects of nest management on a recovering raptor using integrated population modeling

A review of commercial captive breeding of parrots as a supply-side intervention to address unsustainable trade

Genetic Assessment of a Captive Population of Eurasian Stone-Curlew (Burhinus oedicnemus), Source for the Reinforcement of Wild Populations

Conservation Interventions Are Required to Improve Bird Breeding Performance in Artificial Wetlands

Breeding behavior analysis in a large captive colony of African penguins (Spheniscus demersus) and its implications for population management and conservation

Genetic assessment of captive breeding program of Indian Pangolin: implications for conservation and management

The optimal timing of reintroducing captive populations into the wild

Breeding parameters and factors influencing the reproduction of an expanding Long-legged Buzzard (Buteo rufinus) population under high breeding density conditions

Assessing genetic diversity patterns at neutral and adaptive loci to inform population reinforcement of an endangered migratory vulture

Protecting wild bird nests against predators: A systematic review and meta‐analysis of non‐lethal methods