Admixture and reproductive skew shape the conservation value of ex situ populations of the Critically Endangered eastern black rhino

Franziska Elsner-Gearing,Petra Kretzschmar,Susanne Shultz,Mark Pilgrim,Deborah Ann Dawson,Gavin John Horsburgh,Jírí Hruby,Jane Hopper,Tony King,Catherine Walton
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10592-024-01611-z
2024-03-22
Conservation Genetics
Abstract:Abstract Small populations of endangered species risk losing already eroded genetic diversity, important for adaptive potential, through the effects of genetic drift. The magnitude of drift can be mitigated by maximising the effective population size, as is the goal of genetic management strategies. Different mating systems, specifically those leading to reproductive skew, exacerbate genetic drift by distorting contributions. In the absence of an active management strategy, reproductive skew will have long-term effects on the genetic composition of a population, particularly where admixture is present. Here we examine the contrasting effects of conservation management strategies in two ex situ populations of the Critically Endangered eastern black rhino (Diceros bicornis michaeli) , one managed as a semi-wild population in South Africa (SAx), and one managed under a mean-kinship breeding strategy in European zoos. We use molecular data to reconstruct pedigrees for both populations and validate the method using the zoo studbook. Using the reconstructed pedigree and studbook we show there is male sex-specific skew in both populations. However, the zoo’s mean-kinship breeding strategy effectively reduces reproductive skew in comparison to a semi-wild population with little genetic management. We also show that strong male reproductive skew in SAx has resulted in extensive admixture, which may require a re-evaluation of the population’s original intended role in the black rhino meta-population. With a high potential for admixture in many ex situ populations of endangered species, molecular and pedigree data remain vital tools for populations needing to balance drift and selection.
biodiversity conservation,genetics & heredity
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problems does this paper attempt to solve? This paper aims to explore the impact of two different management strategies on the conservation value and genetic diversity of the captive eastern black rhinoceros (Diceros bicornis michaeli) population. Specifically, the study focuses on the following issues: 1. **Genetic drift and effective population size**: - Endangered species with small populations are prone to lose their already - damaged genetic diversity due to genetic drift, which is crucial for their adaptive potential. By maximizing the effective population size (\(N_e\)), the impact of genetic drift can be mitigated. 2. **The impact of reproductive skew**: - Different mating systems, especially those that lead to reproductive skew, can exacerbate genetic drift and distort the contributions of individuals. In the absence of an active management strategy, reproductive skew can have a long - term impact on the genetic composition of the population, especially in the presence of admixture. 3. **Comparison of the effects of two different management strategies**: - The study compared two management strategies for the captive eastern black rhinoceros population: one is the population managed under semi - wild conditions in South Africa (SAx), and the other is the population managed by the mean - kinship breeding strategy in European zoos. By reconstructing family trees from molecular data and verifying the breeding records of zoos, the study shows that male reproductive skew exists in both populations. However, the mean - kinship strategy in zoos effectively reduces reproductive skew, while the semi - wild population has little genetic management. 4. **The impact of admixture**: - Strong male reproductive skew has led to extensive admixture in the SAx population, which may require a re - evaluation of the original role of this population in its black rhinoceros metapopulation. Admixture has a high potential in the captive populations of many endangered species, so molecular and family tree data are crucial for populations that need to balance drift and selection. 5. **Evaluation of conservation strategies**: - The study quantified the contribution of southern ancestors to zoo and SAx populations by analyzing genotype data, and evaluated the effectiveness of different management strategies in regulating reproductive skew and genetic drift, thereby providing a basis for formulating conservation strategies using animals from these two major captive populations. ### Summary By comparing two different management strategies, this paper explores the impact of reproductive skew and admixture on the genetic diversity and conservation value of the captive eastern black rhinoceros population, aiming to provide scientific basis and guidance for future conservation work.