Visibility and Invisibility: Structural, Differential, and Embedded Power in Collaborative Governance of Fisheries

Candace K. May
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/08941920.2015.1072257
2015-10-02
Abstract:A visibility–power framework emerged from a case study of conflict over the use of commercial gill nets in North Carolina fisheries. Findings from field observations, interviews, and analysis of documents, policies, and existing statistics demonstrated that while gill nets were highly visible as a regulatory target regarding environmental protection and conservation, recreational fishing and coastal development were relatively invisible. This has resulted in a decline in the commercial fishing industry, yet also continued impacts on marine wildlife and habitat. The utility of the visibility–power framework is a focus on how different forms of power—structural, embedded, and differential—articulate across levels and scales of collaborative natural resource governance (CNRG) systems to produce outcomes and processes that counter stated goals of sustainability. Visibility and invisibility regarding socioenvironmental relations are produced by the structural power of CNRG systems, the differential power of user groups, and embedded power exerted through the disciplinary tactics of everyday social interactions.
sociology,environmental studies,development studies,regional & urban planning
What problem does this paper attempt to address?