Gazing Inward in Jonathan Lethem’s Chronic City and Teju Cole’s Open City
Daniel O’Gorman
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137506184_3
2015-01-01
Abstract:In her 2012 article ‘The Storytellers of Empire’, Kamila Shamsie argues that ‘with pitifully few exceptions, the [American] 9/11 novel looks at 9/11 the day itself, in New York — think of the most acclaimed novels in that genre: Don DeLillo’s Falling Man, Claire Messud’s The Emperor’s Children or Jonathan Safran Foer’s Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close’.1 This is not to say, Shamsie continues, that ‘September 11, the day itself in New York, is not itself a worthy subject for fiction’.2 Rather, her point is that ‘just as the day itself is only one part of the genre of 9/11 nonfiction books, so it should be with fiction’.3 This desire for novelists to shift their fictional framing of September 11, in a way that places ‘the day itself’ into a complex geopolitical context, is one that is shared by other critics also. Michael Rothberg has argued that ‘[w]hat we need from 9/11 novels are cognitive maps that imagine how US citizenship looks and feels beyond the boundaries of the nation-state, both for Americans and for others’.4 Likewise, as I mentioned in the Introduction, Richard Gray calls upon American novelists to perform a literary ‘enactment of difference’.5 He draws attention to a minority of non-canonical post-9/11 texts that, in his view, ‘reconfigure language, the themes and tropes of American writing in terms that go way beyond bipolar, biracial models. In the process, they become a lexical equivalent of the immigrant encounter, transforming their literary environs just as they are transformed by them — and, in effect, force us to rethink 9/11.’6