Abstract:Background and aim A plateau in oxygen uptake ( V ̇ O 2 ) during an incremental cardiopulmonary exercise test (CPET) to volitional exhaustion appears less likely to occur in special and clinical populations. Secondary maximal oxygen uptake ( V ̇ O 2 max ) criteria have been shown to commonly underestimate the actual V ̇ O 2 max . The verification phase protocol might determine the occurrence of ‘true’ V ̇ O 2 max in these populations. The primary aim of the current study was to systematically review and provide a meta-analysis on the suitability of the verification phase for confirming ‘true’ V ̇ O 2 max in special and clinical groups. Secondary aims were to explore the applicability of the verification phase according to specific participant characteristics and investigate which test protocols and procedures minimise the differences between the highest V ̇ O 2 values attained in the CPET and verification phase. Methods Electronic databases (PubMed, Web of Science, SPORTDiscus, Scopus, and EMBASE) were searched using specific search strategies and relevant data were extracted from primary studies. Studies meeting inclusion criteria were systematically reviewed. Meta-analysis techniques were applied to quantify weighted mean differences (standard deviations) in peak V ̇ O 2 from a CPET and a verification phase within study groups using random-effects models. Subgroup analyses investigated the differences in V ̇ O 2 max according to individual characteristics and test protocols. The methodological quality of the included primary studies was assessed using a modified Downs and Black checklist to obtain a level of evidence. Participant-level V ̇ O 2 data were analysed according to the threshold criteria reported by the studies or the inherent measurement error of the metabolic analysers and displayed as Bland-Altman plots. Results Forty-three studies were included in the systematic review, whilst 30 presented quantitative information for meta-analysis. Within the 30 studies, the highest mean V ̇ O 2 values attained in the CPET and verification phase protocols were similar (mean difference = -0.00 [95% confidence intervals, CI = -0.03 to 0.03] L·min -1 , p = 0.87; level of evidence, LoE: strong). The specific clinical groups with sufficient primary studies to be meta-analysed showed a similar V ̇ O 2 max between the CPET and verification phase ( p > 0.05, LoE: limited to strong). Across all 30 studies, V ̇ O 2 max was not affected by differences in test protocols ( p > 0.05; LoE: moderate to strong). Only 23 (53.5%) of the 43 reviewed studies reported how many participants achieved a lower, equal, or higher V ̇ O 2 value in the verification phase versus the CPET or reported or supplied participant-level V ̇ O 2 data for this information to be obtained. The percentage of participants that achieved a lower, equal, or higher V ̇ O 2 value in the verification phase was highly variable across studies (e.g. the percentage that achieved a higher V ̇ O 2 in the verification phase ranged from 0% to 88.9%). Conclusion Group-level verification phase data appear useful for confirming a specific CPET protocol likely elicited V ̇ O 2 max , or a reproducible V ̇ O 2 p e a k , for a given special or clinical group. Participant-level data might be useful for confirming whether specific participants have likely elicited V ̇ O 2 max , or a reproducible V ̇ O 2 p e a k , however, more research reporting participant-level data is required before evidence-based guidelines can be given. Trial registration PROSPERO ( CRD42021247658 ) https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero .

The Oxygen Uptake Response to Incremental Ramp Exercise

A Comparison of Methods to Identify the Mean Response Time of Ramp-Incremental Exercise for Exercise Prescription

Increases in the incremental exercise mean response time across the steady state domain: Implications for exercise testing & prescription

Identifying time-varying dynamics of heart rate and oxygen uptake from single ramp incremental running tests

Physiological Implication of Slope Gradient during Incremental Running Test

Oxygenation trends in vastus lateralis muscle during incremental and intense anaerobic cycle exercise in young men and women

The Respiratory Compensation Point: Mechanisms and Relation to the Maximal Metabolic Steady State

Combined effect of sprint interval training and post-exercise blood flow restriction on muscle deoxygenation responses during ramp incremental cycling

Roles of Anaerobic Performance and Respiratory Muscle Strength

Aerobic Metabolic Adaptations in Endurance Eccentric Exercise and Training: From Whole Body to Mitochondria

The Dynamics of Locomotor Neuromuscular Fatigue during Ramp-Incremental Cycling to Intolerance

Prescription of high-intensity aerobic interval training based on oxygen uptake kinetics

Exercise training response heterogeneity: physiological and molecular insights

Oxygen uptake response to switching stairs exercise by non-parametric modeling

Relationship among muscle strength, muscle endurance, and skeletal muscle oxygenation dynamics during ramp incremental cycle exercise

Mechanisms of slowed V̇O2 on-kinetics in second step of two-step-incremental exercise in skeletal muscle

Confirming the attainment of maximal oxygen uptake within special and clinical groups: A systematic review and meta-analysis of cardiopulmonary exercise test and verification phase protocols

The delta concept does not effectively normalise exercise responses to exhaustive interval training

Oxygen Uptake Efficiency Slope, an Objective Submaximal Parameter in Evaluating Exercise Capacity in Pulmonary Thromboembolism

End Criteria for Reaching Maximal Oxygen Uptake Must Be Strict and Adjusted to Sex and Age: A Cross-Sectional Study

Cardiopulmonary response to exercise in COPD and overweight patients: relationship between unloaded cycling and maximal oxygen uptake profiles