Abstract:Summary Background Fingertip pulse oximeters are widely available, inexpensive, and commonly used to make clinical decisions in many settings. Device performance is largely unregulated and poorly characterised, especially in people with dark skin pigmentation. Methods Eleven popular fingertip pulse oximeters were evaluated using the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) Guidance (2013) and International Organization for Standardization Standards (ISO, 2017) in 34 healthy humans with diverse skin pigmentation utilising a controlled desaturation study with arterial oxygen saturation (SaO 2) plateaus between 70% and 100%. Skin pigmentation was assessed subjectively using a perceived Fitzpatrick Scale (pFP) and objectively using the individual typology angle (ITA) via spectrophotometry at nine anatomical sites. Findings Five of 11 devices had a root mean square error (ARMS) > 3%, falling outside the acceptable FDA performance range. Nine devices demonstrated worse performance in participants in the darkest skin pigmentation category compared with those in the lightest category. A commonly used subjective skin colour scale frequently miscategorised participants as being darkly pigmented when compared to objective quantification of skin pigment by ITA. Interpretation Fingertip pulse oximeters have variable performance, frequently not meeting regulatory requirements for clinical use, and occasionally contradicting claims made by manufacturers. Most devices showed a trend toward worse performance in participants with darker skin pigment. Regulatory standards do not adequately account for the impact of skin pigmentation on device performance. We recommend that the pFP and other non-standardised subjective skin colour scales should no longer be used for defining diversity of skin pigmentation. Reliable methods for characterising skin pigmentation to improve diversity and equitable performance of pulse oximeters are needed. Funding This study was conducted as part of the Open Oximetry Project funded by the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation , Patrick J McGovern Foundation , and Robert Wood Johnson Foundation . The UCSF Hypoxia Research Laboratory receives funding from multiple industry sponsors to test the sponsors' devices for the purposes of product development and regulatory performance testing. Data in this paper do not include sponsor's study devices. All data were collected from devices procured by the Hypoxia Research Laboratory for the purposes of independent research. No company provided any direct funding for this study, participated in study design or analysis, or was involved in analysing data or writing the manuscript. None of the authors own stock or equity interests in any pulse oximeter companies. Dr Ellis Monk's time utilised for data analysis, reviewing and editing was funded by grant number: DP2MH132941.

Technological Review of Pulse Oximeter Simulators

Everything About Pulse Oximetry—Part 1: History, Principles, Advantages, Limitations, Inaccuracies, Cost Analysis, the Level of Knowledge About Pulse Oximeter Among Clinicians, and Pulse Oximetry Versus Tissue Oximetry

Pulse oximeter bench tests under different simulated skin tones

Tissue mimicking materials and finger phantom design for pulse oximetry

A review of the effect of skin pigmentation on pulse oximeter accuracy

A pulse oximeter for measuring the blood oxygenation level considering the carboxyhemoglobin concentration: principles of development, computer model and accuracy assessment

Pulse oximetry in pediatric care: Balancing advantages and limitations

History and Social Implications of the Pulse Oximeter

Improving the management of patients with chronic cardiac and respiratory diseases by extending pulse-oximeter uses: the dynamic pulse-oximetry

Development of a pulse oximeter robust to measurement errors, with the ability to estimate heartrate and transmit data to smartphones

The Various Oximetric Techniques Used for the Evaluation of Blood Oxygenation

Design and Development of a Low Cost Pulse Oximeter

An Optical Signal Simulator for the Characterization of Photoplethysmographic Devices

Ninety years of pulse oximetry: history, current status, and outlook

Advances and Challenges Associated with Low-Cost Pulse Oximeters in Home Care Programs: A Review

Evaluation of a New Smartphone Powered Low-cost Pulse Oximeter Device

Exploring the impact of pulse oximeter selection within the COVID-19 home-use pulse oximetry pathways

The performance of 11 fingertip pulse oximeters during hypoxemia in healthy human participants with varied, quantified skin pigment

Performance of a novel reusable pediatric pulse oximeter probe

Performance of Wearable Pulse Oximetry During Controlled Hypoxia Induction

Comparison of Pulse Oximetry and Handheld Doppler for Assessing Digital Perfusion