Investment Style Volatility and Mutual Fund Performance
K. Brown
Abstract:We develop a holdings-based statistic to measure the volatility of a fund’s investment style characteristic profile over time. On average, funds with lower levels of style volatility significantly outperform more style-volatile funds on a risk-adjusted basis. We show that style volatility has a distinct impact on future fund performance compared to fund expenses or past risk-adjusted returns, with the level of indirect style volatility being the primary determinant of the overall effect. We conclude that deciding to maintain a less volatile investment style is an important aspect of the portfolio management process. Current Draft: May 28, 2015 We are grateful for the comments of Andres Almazan, Nick Bollen, Mark Carhart, Dave Chapman, Wayne Ferson, Douglas Foster, William Goetzmann, Jennifer Huang, Bob Jones, Robert Litterman, Paula Tkac, Clemens Sialm, Laura Starks, Laurens Swinkels, Sheridan Titman, and Russ Wermers on earlier versions of this study. Earlier versions were also presented at the Financial Management Association European Conference, University of Texas Finance seminar, the Goldman Sachs Asset Management seminar, the Atlanta Federal Reserve Board Financial Markets Conference, and the Erasmus University Conference on Professional Asset Management. The opinions and analyses presented herein are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the views of Putnam Investments. Investment Style Volatility and Mutual Fund Performance ABSTRACT We develop a holdings-based statistic to measure the volatility of a fund’s investment style characteristic profile over time. On average, funds with lower levels of style volatility significantly outperform more style-volatile funds on a risk-adjusted basis. We show that style volatility has a distinct impact on future fund performance compared to fund expenses or past risk-adjusted returns, with the level of indirect style volatility being the primary determinant of the overall effect. We conclude that deciding to maintain a less volatile investment style is an important aspect of the portfolio management process.We develop a holdings-based statistic to measure the volatility of a fund’s investment style characteristic profile over time. On average, funds with lower levels of style volatility significantly outperform more style-volatile funds on a risk-adjusted basis. We show that style volatility has a distinct impact on future fund performance compared to fund expenses or past risk-adjusted returns, with the level of indirect style volatility being the primary determinant of the overall effect. We conclude that deciding to maintain a less volatile investment style is an important aspect of the portfolio management process. JEL Classification: G11, G14
Economics,Business