Abstract:A systematic review of literature was conducted to evaluate the effectiveness of passive countermeasures in ameliorating the cardiopulmonary and musculoskeletal effects of gravitational unloading on humans during spaceflight. This systematic review is the third of a series being conducted by the European Space Agency to evaluate the effectiveness of countermeasures to physiologic deconditioning during spaceflight. With future long-duration space missions on the horizon, it is critical to understand the effectiveness of existing countermeasures to promote astronaut health and improve the probability of future mission success. An updated search for studies examining passive countermeasures was conducted in 2021 to supplement results from a broader search conducted in 2017 for all countermeasures. Ground-based analogue and spaceflight studies were included in the search. A total of 647 articles were screened following removal of duplicates, of which 16 were included in this review. Data extraction and analysis, quality assessment of studies, and transferability of reviewed studies to actual spaceflight based on their bed-rest protocol were conducted using dedicated tools created by the Aerospace Medicine Systematic Review Group. Of the 180 examined outcomes across the reviewed studies, only 20 were shown to have a significant positive effect in favour of the intervention group. Lower body negative pressure was seen to significantly maintain orthostatic tolerance (OT) closer to baseline as comparted to control groups. It also was seen to have mixed efficacy with regards to maintaining resting heart rate close to pre-bed rest values. Whole body vibration significantly maintained many balance-related outcome measures close to pre-bed rest values as compared to control. Skin surface cooling and centrifugation both showed efficacy in maintaining OT. Centrifugation also was seen to have mixed efficacy with regards to maintaining VO2max close to pre-bed rest values. Overall, standalone passive countermeasures showed no significant effect in maintaining 159 unique outcome measures close to their pre-bed rest values as compared to control groups. Risk of bias was rated high or unclear in all studies due to poorly detailed methodologies, poor control of confounding variables, and other sources of bias (i.e. inequitable recruitment of participants leading to a higher male:female ratios). The bed-rest transferability (BR) score varied from 2–7, with a median score of 5. Generally, most studies had good BR transferability but underreported on factors such as control of sunlight or radiation exposure, diet, level of exercise and sleep-cycles. We conclude that: (1) Lack of standardisation of outcome measurement and methodologies has led to large heterogeneity amongst studies; (2) Scarcity of literature and high risk of bias amongst existing studies limits the statistical power of results; and (3) Passive countermeasures have little or no efficacy as standalone measures against cardiopulmonary and musculoskeletal deconditioning induced by spaceflight related to physiologic deterioration due to gravity un-loading.

Physiological effects of weightlessness: countermeasure system development for a long-term Chinese manned spaceflight

Progress of Space Medicine Research in China

Research progress in pharmacokinetics under weightlessness

Onboard physical training in weightless environment: A review

Lower Body Negative Pressure Exposure—as Perspective Countermeasure for Moon Missions

Advances in China Space Medical Experiment Research

Research Trends on Astronaut Physical Training as Countermeasures: A Bibliometric Analysis from Past 30 Years

Dynamics of physical performance during long-duration space flight (first results of "Countermeasure" experiment)

Lower body negative pressure as a research tool and countermeasure for the physiological effects of spaceflight: A comprehensive review

Systematic review of the effectiveness of standalone passive countermeasures on microgravity-induced physiologic deconditioning

A new respiratory training system for astronauts

Research Progress in Effects of Weightlessness/Simulated Weightlessness on Central Nervous System

Time-resolved molecular measurements reveal changes in astronauts during spaceflight

Exercise Countermeasures to Neuromuscular Deconditioning in Spaceflight

The space cold atom interferometer for testing the equivalence principle in the China Space Station

Countermeasures-based Improvements in Stress, Immune System Dysregulation and Latent Herpesvirus Reactivation onboard the International Space Station – Relevance for Deep Space Missions and Terrestrial Medicine

Current Status of Space Radiobiological Studies in China

Physiological compensatory mechanisms of improved left heart function in response to simulated acute weightlessness: A human echocardiographic study by speckle tracking strain imaging

Self-Generated Lower Body Negative Pressure Exercise: A Low Power Countermeasure for Acute Space Missions

Cardiac Effects of Long-Duration Space Flight

Support of Life and Health for Astronauts in Space Station