There’s no limit to longevity, says study that revives human lifespan debate

Elie Dolgin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-018-05582-3

IF: 64.8

2018-06-28

Nature

Abstract:Death rates in later life flatten out and suggest there may be no fixed limit on human longevity, countering some previous work.

multidisciplinary sciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Does the human lifespan have a limit?

Michael Eisenstein

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-022-00070-1

IF: 64.8

2022-01-19

Nature

Abstract:Super-centenarians offer clues as demographers and scientists lock horns over one of the world’s oldest research questions.

multidisciplinary sciences
Is There a Cap on Longevity? A Statistical Review

Léo R. Belzile,Anthony C. Davison,Jutta Gampe,Holger Rootzén,Dmitrii Zholud

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-statistics-040120-025426

IF: 7.9

2022-03-07

Annual Review of Statistics and Its Application

Abstract:There is sustained and widespread interest in understanding the limit, if there is any, to the human life span. Apart from its intrinsic and biological interest, changes in survival in old age have implications for the sustainability of social security systems. A central question is whether the endpoint of the underlying lifetime distribution is finite. Recent analyses of data on the oldest human lifetimes have led to competing claims about survival and to some controversy, due in part to incorrect statistical analysis. This article discusses the particularities of such data, outlines correct ways of handling them, and presents suitable models and methods for their analysis. We provide a critical assessment of some earlier work and illustrate the ideas through reanalysis of semisupercentenarian lifetime data. Our analysis suggests that remaining life length after age 109 is exponentially distributed and that any upper limit lies well beyond the highest lifetime yet reliably recorded. Lower limits to 95% confidence intervals for the human life span are about 130 years, and point estimates typically indicate no upper limit at all.

statistics & probability,mathematics, interdisciplinary applications
Human life is unlimited - but short

Holger Rootzén,Dmitrii Zholud

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1708.02184

2017-08-08

Abstract:Does the human lifespan have an impenetrable biological upper limit which ultimately will stop further increase in life lengths? This question is important for understanding aging, and for society, and has led to intense controversies. Demographic data for humans has been interpreted as showing existence of a limit, or even as an indication of a decreasing limit, but also as evidence that a limit does not exist. This paper studies what can be inferred from data about human mortality at extreme age. We show that in western countries and Japan and after age 110 the probability of dying is about 47% per year. Hence there is no finite upper limit to the human lifespan. Still, given the present stage of biotechnology, it is unlikely that during the next 25 years anyone will live longer than 128 years in these countries. Data, remarkably, shows no difference in mortality after age 110 between sexes, between ages, or between different lifestyles or genetic backgrounds. These results, and the analysis methods developed in this paper, can help testing biological theories of ageing and aid confirmation of success of efforts to find a cure for ageing.

Applications
No limit to maximal lifespan in humans: how to beat a 122-year-old record

Mikhail V. Blagosklonny

DOI: https://doi.org/10.18632/oncoscience.547

2021-12-01

Oncoscience

Abstract:Although average human life expectancy is rising, the maximum lifespan is not increasing. Leading demographers claim that human lifespan is fixed at a natural limit around 122 years. However, there is no fixed limit in animals. In animals, anti-aging interventions (dietary restrictions, rapamycin, genetic manipulations) postpone age-related diseases and thus automatically extend maximum lifespan. In humans, anti-aging interventions have not been yet implemented. Instead, by treating individual diseases, medical interventions allow a patient to live longer (despite morbidity), expanding morbidity span. In contrast, slowly aging individuals (centenarians) enter very old age in good health, but, when diseases finally develop, they do not receive thorough medical care and die fast. Although the oldest old die from age-related diseases, death certificates often list "old age", meaning that diseases were not even diagnosed and even less treated. The concept of absolute compression of morbidity is misleading in humans (in truth, there is no other way to compress morbidity as by denying thorough medical care) and false in animals (in truth, anti-aging interventions do not condense morbidity, they postpone it). Anti-aging interventions such as rapamycin may potentially extend both healthspan and maximal lifespan in humans. Combining anti-aging medicine with cutting-edge medical care, regardless of chronological age, will extend maximal lifespan further.
Telomeres and the natural lifespan limit in humans

Troels Steenstrup,Jeremy D. Kark,Simon Verhulst,Mikael Thinggaard,Jacob V. B. Hjelmborg,Christine Dalgård,Kirsten Ohm Kyvik,Lene Christiansen,Massimo Mangino,Timothy D. Spector,Inge Petersen,Masayuki Kimura,Athanase Benetos,Carlos Labat,Ronit Sinnreich,Shih-Jen Hwang,Daniel Levy,Steven C. Hunt,Annette L. Fitzpatrick,Wei Chen,Gerald S. Berenson,Michelangela Barbieri,Giuseppe Paolisso,Shahinaz M. Gadalla,Sharon A. Savage,Kaare Christensen,Anatoliy I. Yashin,Konstantin G. Arbeev,Abraham Aviv

DOI: https://doi.org/10.18632/aging.101216

2017-04-06

Aging

Abstract:An ongoing debate in demography has focused on whether the human lifespan has a maximal natural limit. Taking a mechanistic perspective, and knowing that short telomeres are associated with diminished longevity, we examined whether telomere length dynamics during adult life could set a maximal natural lifespan limit. We define leukocyte telomere length of 5 kb as the 'telomeric brink', which denotes a high risk of imminent death. We show that a subset of adults may reach the telomeric brink within the current life expectancy and more so for a 100-year life expectancy. Thus, secular trends in life expectancy should confront a biological limit due to crossing the telomeric brink.
Evidence for a limit to human lifespan

Xiao Dong,Brandon Milholland,Jan Vijg

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/nature19793

IF: 64.8

2016-10-05

Nature

Abstract:Demographic analysis of life expectancy and maximum reported age at death provides evidence that human lifespan has reached its natural limit.

multidisciplinary sciences
The dynamic upper limit of human lifespan

Saul Newman,Simon Easteal

DOI: https://doi.org/10.12688/f1000research.11438.2

2017-06-09

F1000Research

Abstract:We respond to claims by Dong et al . that human lifespan is limited below 125 years. Using the log-linear increase in mortality rates with age to predict the upper limits of human survival we find, in contrast to Dong et al ., that the limit to human lifespan is historically flexible and increasing. This discrepancy can be explained by Dong et al .’s use of data with variable sample sizes, age-biased rounding errors, and log(0) instead of log(1) values in linear regressions. Addressing these issues eliminates the proposed 125-year upper limit to human lifespan.
The shortness of human life constitutes its limit

Brandon Milholland,Xiao Dong,Jan Vijg

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1803.04024

2018-03-11

Applications

Abstract:In this paper, we affirm our earlier findings of evidence for a limit to human lifespan. In particular, we assess the analyses in extreme value theory (EVT) performed by Rootz\'en and Zholud. We find that their criticisms of our work are unfounded and that their analyses are contradicted by several other papers using EVT. Furthermore, we find that even if we completely accept the conclusions about late-life human mortality reached by Rootz\'en and Zholud, their results do not actually contradict the findings presented in our original paper: whether unbounded or not, human lifespan is unlikely to greatly exceed 120 years, and the improbability of longer survival---whether it is exactly zero or merely astronomically small---acts as a de facto limit. In order to eliminate the confusion surrounding the issue, we propose the adoption of the term "limit" to denote the age at which the chance of survival is exactly zero and the term "effective limit" to denote the age at which the change of survival falls below a given threshold. Once this distinction is made, it can be demonstrated that the final result of Rootz\'en and Zholud is essentially a recapitulation of the main conclusion of our paper. Ultimately, much of the controversy surrounding the issue of a limit to human lifespan can be avoided by carefully reading the literature and applying statistics to practical human scales.
Longitudinal analysis of blood markers reveals progressive loss of resilience and predicts ultimate human lifespan limit

Timothy V. Pyrkov,Konstantin Avchaciov,Andrei E. Tarkhov,Leonid I. Menshikov,Andrei V. Gudkov,Peter O. Fedichev

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/618876

2019-04-26

Abstract:ABSTRACT We investigated the dynamic properties of the organism state fluctuations along individual aging trajectories in a large longitudinal database of CBC measurements from a consumer diagnostics laboratory. To simplify the analysis, we used a log-linear mortality estimate from the CBC variables as a single quantitative measure of aging process, henceforth referred to as dynamic organism state index (DOSI). We observed, that the age-dependent population DOSI distribution broadening could be explained by a progressive loss of physiological resilience measured by the DOSI auto-correlation time. Extrapolation of this trend suggested that DOSI recovery time and variance would simultaneously diverge at a critical point of 120 − 150 years of age corresponding to a complete loss of resilience. The observation was immediately confirmed by the independent analysis of correlation properties of intraday physical activity levels fluctuations collected by wearable devices. We conclude that the criticality resulting in the end of life is an intrinsic biological property of an organism that is independent of stress factors and signifies a fundamental or absolute limit of human lifespan.
Biological Restraints on Indefinite Survival

Jan Vijg,Steven N Austad

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/cshperspect.a041200

2023-04-03

Abstract:Multiple observations that organismal life span can be extended by nutritional, genetic, or pharmacological intervention has raised the prospect of transforming medicine with the goal of slowing, stopping, or even reversing age-associated disease and maintaining or restoring health and resilience in the increasing numbers of elderly across the world. The potential for such an enterprise is supported in theory by plant and animal models of negligible senescence, most notably the small, freshwater organism Hydra spp. The existence of some very long-lived species, including bowhead whale, Greenland shark, and giant tortoises, suggests that increased healthy life spans in humans, significantly higher than the current known maximum life span of about 120 years, may be possible. Here we discuss the biological restraints on human life extension based on the evolutionary basis of aging and our current genetic and molecular insights into the processes responsible for age-related loss of function and increased disease risk.
Longitudinal analysis of blood markers reveals progressive loss of resilience and predicts human lifespan limit

Timothy V. Pyrkov,Konstantin Avchaciov,Andrei E. Tarkhov,Leonid I. Menshikov,Andrei V. Gudkov,Peter O. Fedichev

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-23014-1

IF: 16.6

2021-05-25

Nature Communications

Abstract:Abstract We investigated the dynamic properties of the organism state fluctuations along individual aging trajectories in a large longitudinal database of CBC measurements from a consumer diagnostics laboratory. To simplify the analysis, we used a log-linear mortality estimate from the CBC variables as a single quantitative measure of the aging process, henceforth referred to as dynamic organism state indicator (DOSI). We observed, that the age-dependent population DOSI distribution broadening could be explained by a progressive loss of physiological resilience measured by the DOSI auto-correlation time. Extrapolation of this trend suggested that DOSI recovery time and variance would simultaneously diverge at a critical point of 120 − 150 years of age corresponding to a complete loss of resilience. The observation was immediately confirmed by the independent analysis of correlation properties of intraday physical activity levels fluctuations collected by wearable devices. We conclude that the criticality resulting in the end of life is an intrinsic biological property of an organism that is independent of stress factors and signifies a fundamental or absolute limit of human lifespan.

multidisciplinary sciences
Socio-economic constraints to maximum human lifespan

Albert Solé-Ribalta,Javier Borge-Holthoefer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1806.11376

2018-06-29

Populations and Evolution

Abstract:The analysis of the demographic transition of the past century and a half, using both empirical data and mathematical models, has rendered a wealth of well-established facts, including the dramatic increases in life expectancy. Despite these insights, such analyses have also occasionally triggered debates which spill over many disciplines, from genetics, to biology, or demography. Perhaps the hottest discussion is happening around the question of maximum human lifespan, which --besides its fascinating historical and philosophical interest-- poses urgent pragmatic warnings on a number of issues in public and private decision-making. In this paper, we add to the controversy some results which, based on purely statistical grounds, suggest that the maximum human lifespan is not fixed, or has not reached yet a plateau. Quite the contrary, analysis on reliable data for over 150 years in more than 20 industrialized countries point at a sustained increase in the maximum age at death. Furthermore, were this trend to continue, a limitless lifespan could be achieved by 2102. Finally, we quantify the dependence of increases in the maximum lifespan on socio-economic factors. Our analysis indicates that in some countries the observed rising patterns can only be sustained by progressively larger increases in GDP, setting the problem of longevity in a context of diminishing returns.
Exploring the limits of life extension

Karen O’Leary

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/d41591-024-00076-4

IF: 82.9

2024-11-01

Nature Medicine

Abstract:The twentieth century saw unprecedented rises in life expectancy in high-income countries, but data suggest that this trend will not continue in the current century without radical interventions to slow biological aging. The twentieth century saw unprecedented rises in life expectancy in high-income countries, but data suggest that this trend will not continue in the current century without radical interventions to slow biological aging.

biochemistry & molecular biology,cell biology,medicine, research & experimental
Predicting Human Lifespan Limits

Byung Mook Weon,Jung Ho Je

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0908.3503

2009-08-28

Abstract:Recent discoveries show steady improvements in life expectancy during modern decades. Does this support that humans continue to live longer in future? We recently put forward the maximum survival tendency, as found in survival curves of industrialized countries, which is described by extended Weibull model with age-dependent stretched exponent. The maximum survival tendency suggests that human survival dynamics may possess its intrinsic limit, beyond which survival is inevitably forbidden. Based on such tendency, we develop the model and explore the patterns in the maximum lifespan limits from industrialized countries during recent three decades. This analysis strategy is simple and useful to interpret the complicated human survival dynamics.

Populations and Evolution,Quantitative Methods
Forever young: what science can and can't tell us about cheating ageing

Jan H. J. Hoeijmakers

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-024-02677-y

IF: 64.8

2024-08-23

Nature

Abstract:High-profile advances, such as anti-ageing drugs called senolytics, have sparked hope that old age and death could be postponed considerably, and have even fostered fantasies of eternal life. But the reality is more nuanced. High-profile advances, such as anti-ageing drugs called senolytics, have sparked hope that old age and death could be postponed considerably, and have even fostered fantasies of eternal life. But the reality is more nuanced.

multidisciplinary sciences
A universal limit for mammalian lifespan revealed by epigenetic entropy

Juan José Alba-Linares,Juan Ramón Tejedor,Agustín F. Fernández,Raúl F. Pérez,Mario F. Fraga

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.09.06.611669

2024-09-06

Abstract:Age-associated DNA methylation patterns have shown strong associations with species lifespan. However, it remains unclear whether epigenetic noise levels can account for the observed differences between mammalian species. In this study, we examined the rate of loss of epigenetic information with age by measuring entropy at mammalian conserved CpG sites across a diverse range of species. Longer-lived mammals tend to gain fewer noisy CpGs with age, irrespective of whether these originate from hyper- or hypomethylation processes. Importantly, we found that the rate of epigenetic entropy gain declines in a linear fashion with species maximum lifespan, pointing to the existence of a universal limit for mammalian lifespan in the vicinity of 220 years.

Molecular Biology
Life expectancy rise in rich countries slows down: why discovery took 30 years to prove

David Adam

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-024-03244-1

IF: 64.8

2024-10-08

Nature

Abstract:Improvements in public health and medicine have lengthened human survival, but science has yet to overcome ageing. Improvements in public health and medicine have lengthened human survival, but science has yet to overcome ageing.

multidisciplinary sciences
Why Gilgamesh failed: the mechanistic basis of the limits to human lifespan

Brandon Milholland,Jan Vijg

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s43587-022-00291-z

Abstract:The purpose of this Perspective is to clarify for an interdisciplinary audience the fundamental concepts of human longevity and provide evidence for a limit to human lifespan. This observed limit is placed into a broader framework by showing how it has arisen through the process of evolution and by enumerating the molecular mechanisms that may enforce it. Finally, we look toward potential future developments and the prospects for possibly circumventing the current limit.
Is increased longevity leading to compression or expansion of morbidity? -- Evidence from cohorts of the oldest-old in China Brief Title: Is increased longevity leading to compressed or expansion of morbidity?

Yi Zeng,Qiushi Feng,Therese Hesketh,Kaare Christensen,James Vaupel

2017-01-01

Abstract:Acknowledgments We are grateful to Xiaomin Shi, Zhaoxue Yin, Jieshi Luo and Yuebin Lv from China Center for Diseases Control and Prevention; Yuzhi Liu, Chunyuan Zhang, Yun Zhou and Zhenzhen Zheng from Peking University; Zhenyu Xiao, Liqun Tao, Qin Xu and Ye Yuan from Chinese Center for Aging Science Research; and Jie Zhan from China Social Science Academy for their contributions to the Chinese Longitudinal Healthy Longevity Survey (CLHLS), and we thank all interviewees and their families for their voluntary participation in the CLHLS study. We are very grateful for comments provided by Danan Gu and research assistance provided by Huashuai Chen and Muqi Guo.
Dissecting the Mechanisms Underlying Unusually Successful Human Health Span and Life Span

Sofiya Milman,Nir Barzilai

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/cshperspect.a025098

2015-12-04

Abstract:Humans age at different rates and families with exceptional survival provide the opportunity to understand why some people age slower than others. Unique features exhibited by centenarians include a family history of longevity, compression of morbidity with resultant extension of health span, and biomarkers such as low-circulating insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1) and elevated high-density lipoprotein (HDL) cholesterol levels. Given the rarity of the centenarian phenotype, it has not been surprising that the use of discovery methods that relied on common population single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) to unlock the genetic determinants of exceptional longevity have not yielded significant results. Conversely, gene sequencing has resulted in discoveries of functional gene variants that support several of the centenarian phenotypes. These discoveries have led to the strategic developments of drugs that may delay aging and prolong health span.

There’s no limit to longevity, says study that revives human lifespan debate

Does the human lifespan have a limit?

Is There a Cap on Longevity? A Statistical Review

Human life is unlimited - but short

No limit to maximal lifespan in humans: how to beat a 122-year-old record

Telomeres and the natural lifespan limit in humans

Evidence for a limit to human lifespan

The dynamic upper limit of human lifespan

The shortness of human life constitutes its limit

Longitudinal analysis of blood markers reveals progressive loss of resilience and predicts ultimate human lifespan limit

Biological Restraints on Indefinite Survival

Longitudinal analysis of blood markers reveals progressive loss of resilience and predicts human lifespan limit

Socio-economic constraints to maximum human lifespan

Exploring the limits of life extension

Predicting Human Lifespan Limits

Forever young: what science can and can't tell us about cheating ageing

A universal limit for mammalian lifespan revealed by epigenetic entropy

Life expectancy rise in rich countries slows down: why discovery took 30 years to prove

Why Gilgamesh failed: the mechanistic basis of the limits to human lifespan

Is increased longevity leading to compression or expansion of morbidity? -- Evidence from cohorts of the oldest-old in China Brief Title: Is increased longevity leading to compressed or expansion of morbidity?

Dissecting the Mechanisms Underlying Unusually Successful Human Health Span and Life Span