Abstract:The presence of constant abiotic noise near streams may have affected the evolution of spectral components of anuran calls without affecting, at least to the same extent, the evolution of the temporal components. We tested this hypothesis using a phylogenetic signal approach in two clades of Neotropical frogs whose calling and breeding behaviour is associated to streams (genus Hyloscirtus, and Centrolenidae) and in one clade associated to ponds (Phyllomedusinae). Our results suggest that abiotic noise on streams can shape the evolution of call traits in anurans. However, its effect can differ between components of the calls and between clades. In this way, noise on streams can be one of several factors promoting an uncoupled evolutionary pattern between temporal and spectral components of the anuran calls and the high diversity of call structures in anurans. The use of high‐pitched auditory signals by species communicating alongside noisy streams has been often considered an adaptation, yet studies testing this hypothesis have yielded inconclusive results. The major challenge has been to quantify the proportion of across‐species signal variation that could be attributed to either common history (phylogenetic load) or adaptation. We further advance in this approach by comparing the phylogenetic load between different components of anuran calls. Because stream noise allegedly represents a stronger selective pressure for call frequency than for call temporal traits, we predicted a weaker phylogenetic signal in call frequency, particularly in the taxa that breed alongside streams. We first built a phylogenetic hypothesis using four mitochondrial genes on each of three clades: the genus Hyloscirtus and the family Centrolenidae, which call alongside streams and the subfamily Phyllomedusinae, known to call at lentic water bodies. In parallel, we compiled data on the advertisement calls of 154 species and used them to calculate Blomberg's K values as a proxy for the phylogenetic load (signal) of the call traits. The phylogenetic signal was weaker in spectral than in temporal call traits within the Hyloscirtus calls and weak or absent in both spectral and temporal components of Phyllomedusine calls. Against our expectations, the phylogenetic signal was strong in call frequency, but absent in call temporal components of the centrolenid calls. Our results support uncoupled evolution between spectral and temporal components of anuran calls. They also indicate that the selective role of abiotic noise varies among taxa and that other factors must be invoked to fully understand among‐species variation in advertisement calls.

Males increase call frequency, not intensity, in response to noise, revealing no Lombard effect in the little torrent frog

Sometimes Noise is Beneficial: Stream Noise Informs Vocal Communication in the Little Torrent Frog

Sometimes Noise is Beneficial: Stream Noise Informs Vocal Communication in the Little Torrent Frog Amolops Torrentis.

Noise Constrains the Evolution of Call Frequency Contours in Flowing Water Frogs: a Comparative Analysis in Two Clades

Consistency in responses to conspecific advertisement calls with various signal-to-noise ratios in both sexes of the Anhui tree frog

Females and Males Respond Differently to Calls Impaired by Noise in a Tree Frog

An Exception to the Matched Filter Hypothesis: A Mismatch of Male Call Frequency and Female Best Hearing Frequency in A Torrent Frog

Movement or plasticity: acoustic responses of a torrent frog to stream geophony

Changes in call properties of Boana pulchella (Anura, Hylidae) in response to different noise conditions

Male-male Competition and Female Choice Are Differentially Affected by Male Call Acoustics in the Serrate-Legged Small Treefrog, Kurixalus Odontotarsus.

Lung mediated auditory contrast enhancement improves the Signal-to-noise ratio for communication in frogs

Effects of traffic noise on the calling behavior of two Neotropical hylid frogs

Differential Effect of Aircraft Noise on the Spectral-Temporal Acoustic Characteristics of Frog Species

The effects of anthropogenic noise on frogs housed on exhibit at a public aquarium

Auditory Sensitivity Changes with Diurnal Temperature Variation in Little Torrent Frogs (amolops Torrentis)

Little effect of natural noise on high-frequency hearing in frogs, Odorrana tormota

Flexibility as a Strategy for Avoiding Call Overlap in Male Anhui Treefrogs

Uncoupled Evolutionary Patterns in Spectral and Temporal Components of Acoustic Signals in Anurans Associated With Streams

Noise affects mate choice based on visual information via cross-sensory interference

Behavioral and Neurogenomic Responses to Acoustic and Visual Sexual Cues are Correlated in Female Torrent Frogs

The Spectral Structure of Vocalizations Match Hearing Sensitivity but Imprecisely in Philautus Odontotarsus