Making the case for context: Creating value from market research history

Daniel Nunan,Anca C Yallop

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/1470785319847648

2019-05-06

International Journal of Market Research

Abstract:International Journal of Market Research, Ahead of Print.

business

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Seeing the Bigger Picture: Why Market Research History Matters?

Robert Crawford

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/14707853211067701

2022-01-22

International Journal of Market Research

Abstract:Market researchers and the market research industry more generally have paid little attention to the history of market research. This inattention to the past has not only resulted in a significant gap in our knowledge of market research and history more generally, it has also obscured the benefits that can be derived from an understanding of history. Using letters, reports and survey contained in the Ashby Research Service archive at the State Library of New South Wales in Australia, this article seeks to illustrate the benefits to be derived from undertaking historical research on market research and those involved in the market research business. By examining some of the cultural factors informing market research business practices and the ways that the marketing and the media industries have interacted with market researchers, this article not only takes step in addressing the gap in our knowledge of market research history, it also demonstrates the relevance and importance of market research history for business and marketing historians and, indeed, market research scholars and practitioners.

business
Reconciling theory and context: How the case study can set a new agenda for international business research

Catherine Welch,Eriikka Paavilainen-Mäntymäki,Rebecca Piekkari,Emmanuella Plakoyiannaki

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/s41267-021-00484-5

IF: 11.6

2022-01-14

Journal of International Business Studies

Abstract:In our Decade Award-winning article from 2011 we argued that it is not possible to explain social phenomena without consideration of their contexts. However, a persistent assumption in international business (IB) is that theories should be context-free. This affects the methodological choices we make, favoring the inductive theory-building approach to theorizing from case studies. In 2011, we proposed an alternative – contextualized explanations – that in our view better utilizes the main strength of the case study: reconciling theory and context. In this Retrospective, we further develop our original argument that context is essential, and not a hindrance, to theorizing, as well as elaborate on how decontextualization impoverishes theoretical insights. In order to achieve contextualized explanation, we offer four alternatives: process research, historical research, the extended case method, and configurational theorizing. We argue that, for the IB field to take contextualization seriously, we need an open debate about what theory is and how we produce it. We hope this paper will broaden the scope of our discussion from the need for methodological pluralism to the need for theoretical pluralism, thereby setting a new agenda for future IB research.

management,business
Marketing, the past and corporate heritage

John M. T. Balmer,Mario Burghausen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/1470593118790636

2018-08-02

Marketing Theory

Abstract:We argue for a more expansive conceptualization of the past’s relevance in, and for, marketing. Such a differentiated approach to the past is pregnant with possibilities in terms of advancing scholarship apropos temporal agency in marketing along with consumption practices. Symptomatic of this perspective is the increased mindfulness of the rich palate of past-related concepts. Significantly, the corporate heritage notion – because of its omnitemporal nature – represents a distinct and meaningful vector on the past by coalescing the past, present and future into a new type of temporality. As such, the authors reason this expansive conceptualization of ‘the past-in-marketing’ is both timely and efficacious. While sensitive of the importance of the historical method in marketing and the history of marketing scholarship and practice per se, this broader marketing approach to and of the past highlights the ideational and material manifestations of the past-in-the-present and an envisaged past-in-the-future.

business
In Researching Emerging Markets, Anthropology Often Trumps Statistics

Christopher Hylton Fitzroy Nailer,Bruce William Stening,Marina Yue Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2501/ijmr-2015-014

2015-01-01

International Journal of Market Research

Abstract:For reasons primarily associated with the reliability of the data it generates, the timeliness with which it can be produced (and hence its relevance) and its limitations in handling context-sensitive issues, market research in emerging markets that relies too heavily on quantitative methodologies has considerable limitations. For this reason, there has been an increasing realisation that qualitative methods, emphasising data richness and a deep understanding of consumers – 'why' as well as 'what' and 'how much' – are a critical component of research in emerging markets. This paper proposes an approach that integrates quantitative and qualitative methods. It argues that a thorough understanding of emerging markets requires a mind-set and set of skills akin to those of an anthropologist, and sets out how these can be acquired.
Historizing the present: Research agenda and implications for consumer behavior

Dafna Goor,Anat Keinan,Nailya Ordabayeva

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/jcpy.1417

IF: 4.551

2024-03-13

Journal of Consumer Psychology

Abstract:This paper conceptualizes the phenomenon of historizing the present, defined as emphasizing the historical significance of present events and treating the present from the perspective of history. The authors identify four modes of historizing the present (emphasizing that: (1) the present will shape history; (2) the present is a unique moment in history; (3) the present will be remembered in history; (4) the present echoes history) and demonstrate how historizing can be employed by marketers of for‐profit and nonprofit organizations in a variety of contexts. The paper examines the psychological implications of appreciating the historical significance of the present and outlines a research agenda for studying the downstream behavioral consequences of historizing the present across diverse substantive consumer domains. It concludes with an examination of the broader societal implications of historizing the present as well as its implications for consumer well‐being.

psychology, applied,business
Oral History and the Business History of Emerging Markets

GEOFFREY JONES,RACHAEL COMUNALE

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/eso.2018.109

2019-01-30

Abstract:This article highlights the benefits that rigorous use of oral history can offer to research on the contemporary business history of emerging markets. Oral history can help fill some of the major information voids arising from the absence of a strong tradition of creating and making accessible corporate archives in most countries in Africa, Asia, and Latin America. It also permits a level of nuance that is hard to obtain even if written archives are accessible. Oral histories provide insights into why events did not occur, and why companies have chosen certain industries over others. Oral history can also shed light on hyper-sensitive topics, such corruption, which are rarely formally documented.

history of social sciences,business
Historical research with Chinese multilateral historical marketing sources

Tony Yan,Michael R. Hyman

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/jhrm-09-2021-0044

2021-11-05

Journal of Historical Research in Marketing

Abstract:Purpose The rich primary and secondary data sources for studying historical Chinese marketing theory and practice are discussed. This paper aims to briefly address possible challenges (and their solutions) to using these sources. Design/methodology/approach A bibliographic review is used to analyze historical sources pertaining to Chinese marketing theory and practice. Findings Marketing scholars can draw from multiple but neglected and underused Chinese sources to glean important historical data reflecting pre-1949 Chinese marketing. Research limitations/implications Underused Chinese multilateral historical marketing materials are inalienable to extending historical marketing study. Many studies about marketing theory and practice are amenable to such materials. Practical implications By scrutinizing these materials, contemporary marketers can formulate parallel strategies from the repertoire of historical marketing strategies. Originality/value This is the first comprehensive survey of an invaluable non-Western source for historical research in marketing.
Making sense of market segmentation: a fashion retailing case

Lee Quinn,Tony Hines,David Bennison

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/03090560710737552

IF: 5.181

2007-06-05

European Journal of Marketing

Abstract:Purpose The purpose is: first to review the marketing segmentation literature and its antecedents; second, to evaluate the organizational practice of marketing segmentation in a specific commercial context noted for its dynamism and complexity, fashion retailing; third, to assess theoretical and practical implications; and finally to identify an agenda for future research. Design/methodology/approach Through the analysis of an instrumental case study examining practice in fashion retailing this paper makes a contribution to current market segmentation debates. Sensemaking properties are used as a disciplined structure in which to report the case and make sense of segmentation. Findings This research demonstrates that the definition and scope of market segmentation is broader than the current marketing literature suggests. In practice, based on evidence from this research, contemporary segmentation solutions include implicit assumptions, judgement and compressed experience, which are latent within the modelling processes. Research limitations/implications Further research needs to be extended to different organizational settings in order to develop further our understanding of the tacit and intuitive aspects of segmentation decisions. Practical implications Intuitive decision‐making processes and tacit knowledge employed in them are difficult to replicate and make explicit. However, a better understanding of these intuitive processes would offer practitioners an opportunity to systematically improve the quality of decision‐making. Originality/value This research broadens normative theoretical perspectives on market segmentation by highlighting intuitive and tacit dimensions. Combining sensemaking within the case study analysis has helped structure thought trials to provide a rare qualitative insight into the managerial construction of segmentation.

business
Digitised historic newspapers as a primary source for marketing historians

Richard A. Hawkins

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/jhrm-08-2021-0036

2022-04-11

Journal of Historical Research in Marketing

Abstract:Purpose This study aims to highlight the potential of digitised historic newspapers. Design/methodology/approach This paper is a review of digitised historic newspapers as a primary source for marketing historians. It provides a survey of what is available internationally free of charge to the user. It also includes examples of the use of digitised historic newspapers drawn from the author’s own research. Findings The paper reveals the huge potential for marketing historians of what is now available in a growing number of countries across the world. Much of this material is available free of charge to researchers with a connection to the internet. Originality/value To the best of the author’s knowledge, this is the first paper to explore digitised historic newspapers as a primary source for marketing historians.
Applying netnography to market research: The case of the online forum

Jiyao Xun,Jonathan Reynolds

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/jt.2009.29

2010-01-01

Abstract:Although the notion of netnography as a set of tools for exploring consumer behaviour online is not new, the potential of netnographic methods in market research and analysis is still largely undeveloped. In this article, we explore the ways in which netnographic techniques can be used in particular to understand the characteristics and effectiveness of electronic word-of-mouth, an increasingly significant influence on the consumer's decision-making process. We provide an assessment of the main strengths, weaknesses and ethical concerns associated with the use of netnographic techniques. Unlike previous online ethnographic studies that have tended to employ broader socio-cultural observations, we analyse consumers’ information-gathering and purchasing activities on a discussion forum. We relate our findings to a model that sets out three components of communications effectiveness: modes of persuasion that are based on authority, emotion or logic. We conclude by reviewing the implications of netnography for both academic research and marketing practice.
The past, present, and future of brand research

Travis Tae Oh,Kevin Lane Keller,Scott A. Neslin,David J. Reibstein,Donald R. Lehmann

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11002-020-09524-w

IF: 3.426

2020-06-04

Marketing Letters

Abstract:This article discusses the past, present, and future of brand research. We begin by reviewing three historical eras of branding development in the past: the information, attribute, and brand equity eras. Each era is marked by an emphasis on a particular concept of brands and a dominant research methodology during that period. We characterize the present of brand research as the branding era, in which brands have become part of the everyday vocabulary, and the concept of "branding" has been embraced by all types of organizations and people. Finally, we share our perspective on the future of brand research by discussing three major shifts in the brand landscape, mostly influenced by technological advancements such as IoT and their capacity to collect granular data at the individual level. We anticipate that new, exciting opportunities in brand research will continue to open up at the intersection of brands, technologies, and people.

business
The history of academic research in marketing and its implications for the future

Brian T. Ratchford

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/sjme-11-2019-0096

2020-02-10

Abstract:Purpose The purpose of this study is to determine what the history of research in marketing implies for the reaction of the field to recent developments in technology due to the internet and associated developments. Design/methodology/approach This paper examines the introduction of new research topics over 10-year intervals from 1960 to the present. These provide the basic body of knowledge that drives the field at the present time. Findings While researchers have always borrowed techniques, they have refined them to make them applicable to marketing problems. Moreover, the field has always responded to new developments in technology, such as more powerful computers, scanners and scanner data, and the internet with a flurry of research that applies the technologies. Research limitations/implications Marketing will adapt to changes brought on by the internet, increased computer power and big data. While the field faces competition for other disciplines, its established body of knowledge about solving marketing problems gives it a unique advantage. Originality/value This paper traces the history of academic marketing from 1960 to the present to show how major changes in the field responded to changes in computer power and technology. It also derives implications for the future from this analysis.
The crucial role of research in multicultural and cross‐cultural communication

Jim R. Macnamara

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/13632540410807727

2004-07-01

Journal of Communication Management

Abstract:Research is recognised as an essential part of planning and evaluation in most areas of marketing and corporate communication, including advertising, direct marketing and, increasingly, public relations and corporate communication disciplines such as employee communication and community relations. Understanding of audience interests, awareness, perceptions and information needs is critical to strategic planning of communication campaigns. Secondly, identification and quantification of changes in awareness, perception and, ultimately, behaviour is necessary to evaluate objectively the effectiveness of communication (ie the outcomes or results). Nowhere is research more important than in multicultural and cross‐cultural communication. International relations began with human migrations and trade and reach new levels today with globalisation, corporations, organisations and governments increasingly seeking to create consistencies and shared values across divergent cultural groups. They seek to create consistencies and shared values in relation to products (eg Coca‐Cola, IBM, McDonalds), policies (eg trade agreements) and in popular culture such as films, television programmes and news media. Social rules and shared values, ie the culture of communities, affect organisations seeking to communicate multiculturally and cross‐culturally at two levels. First, the “home” culture of the organisation wishing to communicate shapes policies, plans and products that are produced. Secondly, the cultures of audiences inform and substantially shape their interpretation and use of information. Often, multicultural and cross‐cultural communication is a case of “Chinese whispers” on an international scale. What one says or shows is frequently not what others hear or see. Studies cited in this paper show that culture is a vitally important factor in communication. Yet, companies and even governments attempt communication with little understanding of audiences which they wish to reach and with which they wish to build relationships and understanding. This paper examines cultural considerations specifically in the field of public relations and corporate communication in the Asia Pacific region which is comprised of a diverse range of cultures and has been identified as the largest market in the world. Thus, it is increasingly a focal point of global communication campaigns.

English Else
Context Adaptivity as Enabler for Meaningful Pervasive Advertising

Christine Bauer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1912.01490

2019-11-17

Other Computer Science

Abstract:Socio-demographic user profiles are currently regarded as the most convenient base for successful personalized advertising. However, signs point to the dormant power of context recognition. While technologies that can sense the environment are increasingly advanced, questions such as what to sense and how to adapt to a consumer's context are largely unanswered. Research in the field is scattered and frequently prototype-driven. What the community lacks is a thorough methodology to provide the basis for any context-adaptive system: conceptualizing context. This position paper describes our current research of conceptualizing context for pervasive advertising. It summarizes findings from literature analysis and proposes a methodology for context conceptualization, which is currently work-in-progress.
From direct marketing to interactive marketing: a retrospective review of the Journal of Research in Interactive Marketing

Weng Marc Lim,Satish Kumar,Nitesh Pandey,Tareq Rasul,Vidhu Gaur

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/jrim-11-2021-0276

IF: 10.176

2022-04-05

Journal of Research in Interactive Marketing

Abstract:Purpose This study aims to present a retrospective of the Journal of Research in Interactive Marketing (JRIM) on its 15th anniversary. The retrospective includes an analysis of JRIM's growth in publication and citation, and an exploration of the journal's major themes and methodologies employed. Design/methodology/approach This study used a bibliometric methodology consisting of analytical techniques such as performance analysis, co-authorship network analysis, and bibliographic coupling to present a retrospective of JRIM . Findings This study finds that JRIM has grown consistently in terms of its publications and citations with its major themes being social media, advertising and communication, technology adoption, customer behavior, multi-channel marketing, viral marketing, and relationship marketing. This study also reveals that the journal's contributing authors tend to employ empirical and quantitative methodologies. Originality/value This is the first study to present a retrospective of JRIM and one of the few that present a retrospective of interactive marketing. Besides presenting the major themes, this study also analyzes the growth that such themes have undergone with time and what are the major themes in recent times in relation to the body of knowledge on interactive marketing curated through JRIM .

business
Research Constituents, Intellectual Structure, and Collaboration Patterns in Journal of International Marketing: An Analytical Retrospective

Naveen Donthu,Satish Kumar,Nitesh Pandey,Weng Marc Lim

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/1069031X211004234

2021-04-23

Journal of International Marketing

Abstract:Journal of International Marketing, Ahead of Print. This study presents a retrospective on Journal of International Marketing using bibliometrics. The study finds that the journal's run has been characterized by continuous growth in publications and citations, with a dominant contribution base of authors from the United States. Authors have consistently shown a strong preference for quantitative research, with a decline in preference for qualitative research and a negligible increase in preference for mixed-methods research in recent years. The major themes in the journal include global branding, internationalization, cross-cultural marketing, and international relationship marketing. An exploration of the factors affecting article citations reveals that article attributes such as the conceptual method, empirical method, article length, title length, article age, and number of keywords play significant roles in increasing the number of citations. Authors affiliated with nonacademic institutions also have a significant and positive influence on total citations. The article concludes with directions for further research.

business
Hedonic and utilitarian shopping goals: a decade later

Eileen Bridges

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/21639159.2018.1439398

2018-06-13

Journal of Global Scholars of Marketing Science

Abstract:I am pleased to be invited to share some thoughts about my article on the topic of hedonic and utilitarian shopping goals, which was co-authored by Renée Florsheim and published in the Journal of Business Research in 2008. Our article is among the most-cited ever to appear in the Journal of Business Research (JBR), which is quite an honor for us as authors as well as a strong statement about the importance of the topic. What I have done in this invited article is to begin by describing the process by which we developed our ideas, then briefly revisit our key findings, and discuss in some detail the directions that have been taken by later researchers citing our seminal work. Finally, I conclude with ideas on some of the factors that influence how a paper becomes widely cited and suggest areas of further research that could build upon this work.
What value market research?

L Maris

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/sj.bdj.4808236

1993-08-07

Abstract:Whether you have just left your hotel, purchased a new car or eaten at a roadside café, the chances are someone will have asked your views about their services, products and delivery. Why? Perhaps because the market oriented business knows better than to assume it understands its customers. A safer approach is to seek their views through market research, and that is the approach the new Quality Development Awards initiated by the BDJ, Denplan and Colgate have taken.
Putting qualitative international business research in context(s)

A. Rebecca Reuber,Eileen Fischer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/s41267-021-00478-3

IF: 11.6

2021-11-23

Journal of International Business Studies

Abstract:Abstract The Welch et al. (J Int Bus Stud 42(5):740–762, 2011) JIBS Decade Award-winning article highlights the importance of the contextualization of international business research that is based on qualitative research methods. In this commentary, we build on their foundation and develop further the role of contextualization, in terms of the international business phenomena under study, contemporaneous conversations about qualitative research methods, and the situatedness of individual papers within the broader research process. Our remarks are largely targeted to authors submitting international business papers based on qualitative research, and to the gatekeepers – editors and reviewers – assessing them, and we provide some guidance with respect to these three dimensions of context.

management,business
Context factors perceived important when looking for similar experiences in decision‐making for software components: An interview study

Efi Papatheocharous,Claes Wohlin,Deepika Badampudi,Jan Carlson,Krzysztof Wnuk

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/smr.2668

2024-04-12

Journal of Software Evolution and Process

Abstract:With this interview study, which focuses on which context factors are perceived as important by practitioners when reusing previous knowledge on software component reuse, we contribute with a listing of factors perceived to be important when reusing experiences from other prior decision‐making cases of selecting among software components options. During software evolution, decisions related to components' origin or source significantly impact the quality properties of the product and development metrics such as cost, time to market, ease of maintenance, and further evolution. Thus, such decisions should ideally be supported by evidence, i.e., using previous experiences and information from different sources, even own previous experiences. A hindering factor to such reuse of previous experiences is that these decisions are highly context‐dependent and it is difficult to identify when previous experiences come from sufficiently similar contexts to be useful in a current setting. Conversely, when documenting a decision (as a decision experience), it is difficult to know which context factors will be most beneficial when reusing the experience in the future. An interview study is performed to identify a list of context factors that are perceived to be most important by practitioners when using experiences to support decision‐making for component sourcing, using a specific scenario with alternative sources of experiences. We observed that the further away (from a company or an interviewee) the experience evidence is, as is the case for online experiences, the more context factors are perceived as important by practitioners to make use of the experience. Furthermore, we discuss and identify further research to make this type of decision‐making more evidence‐based.

computer science, software engineering

Making the case for context: Creating value from market research history

Seeing the Bigger Picture: Why Market Research History Matters?

Reconciling theory and context: How the case study can set a new agenda for international business research

Marketing, the past and corporate heritage

In Researching Emerging Markets, Anthropology Often Trumps Statistics

Historizing the present: Research agenda and implications for consumer behavior

Oral History and the Business History of Emerging Markets

Historical research with Chinese multilateral historical marketing sources

Making sense of market segmentation: a fashion retailing case

Digitised historic newspapers as a primary source for marketing historians

Applying netnography to market research: The case of the online forum

The past, present, and future of brand research

The history of academic research in marketing and its implications for the future

The crucial role of research in multicultural and cross‐cultural communication

Context Adaptivity as Enabler for Meaningful Pervasive Advertising

From direct marketing to interactive marketing: a retrospective review of the Journal of Research in Interactive Marketing

Research Constituents, Intellectual Structure, and Collaboration Patterns in Journal of International Marketing: An Analytical Retrospective

Hedonic and utilitarian shopping goals: a decade later

What value market research?

Putting qualitative international business research in context(s)

Context factors perceived important when looking for similar experiences in decision‐making for software components: An interview study