Abstract:The tragedy of the commons refers to the overuse of resources which are rival in consumption but lack excludability and it also refers to rent dissipation. While the tragedy of the anticommons is a tragedy closely connected with underuse of resources that are rival in consumption and with too strong excludability. The prior studies proved that the tragedy of the commons and the tragedy of the anticommons are symmetric from the perspective of pure mathematics, especially the game theory, which was later refuted by behavioral economics experiments. According to them, the tragedy of the anticommons is severer than the tragedy of the commons. The asymmetry of the tragedy of the commons and the tragedy of the anticommons is a paradox by these different research methods. This paradox shows that there are imperfections in the completely rational economic man hypothesis set up by neoclassical economics. As a fundamental theory, the tragedy of the commons is quite influential in many disciplines, such as microeconomics, public sector economics, ecological economics, environmental economics, management, sociology, property law, and political science. And the tragedy of the anticommons theory has also opened its door of both theoretical research and practical implications since its acceptance by Nobel laureate Buchanan, the main founder of public choice school. Only when theoretical issues are thoroughly discussed and made clear enough, can people avoid misunderstanding or misusing the commons theory. Thus, it is necessary to elucidate the paradox between them. Based on Simon's bounded rationality, Kahneman and Tversky's prospect theory, value function, Thaler's mental accounting, endowment effect, and other cognitive psychological tools, this study clearly shows that agents' decision-making process is not just based on the long-believed marginal benefit and marginal cost analysis advocated by traditional neoclassical economists. Agents' decision-making is a process in which agents selectively absorb, code the objective marginal revenue and marginal cost, and feed relevant information to their brain. Therefore, what plays a directly decisive role is not the objective marginal revenue and marginal cost per se , but the mentally perceived subjective utility of marginal revenue and marginal cost by the human brain. Followed by this research clue, the paradox between the tragedy of the commons and the tragedy of the anticommons is elucidated from the perspective of cognitive psychology.

Tragedy of the Commons after 50 Years

Tragedy revisited

The Tragedy of ‘The Tragedy of the Commons’ – Hardin vs. the Property Rights Theorists

Framing Institutional Choice, 1937–1973: New Institutional Economics and the Neglect of the Commons

Understanding the paradox between tragedies of the commons and the anticommons: From a cognitive psychology perspective

A Knowledge Producer's View on the Knowledge Commons

Polycentric and resilient perspectives for governing the commons: Strategic and law and economics insights for sustainable development

Spatial interactions and oscillatory tragedies of the commons

William D. Nordhaus Managing the Commons: The Economics of Climate Change, Cambridge, MA, The MIT Press, 1994, ISBN 0-262-140551-1

The tragedy of the commons: a Mean-Field Game approach to the reversal of travelling waves

The Tragedy of the Anticommons in Knowledge

John R. Commons and the Thesis of the Centrality of Work in Human Life

Commons under the Common Law and the Governance Structure of the Park

An oscillating tragedy of the commons in replicator dynamics with game-environment feedback

Preventing the Tragedy of the Commons Through Punishment of Over-Consumers and Encouragement of Under-Consumers

Tragedy of the commons or tragedy of privatisation? The impact of land tenure reform on grassland condition in Inner Mongolia, China

The Tragedy of the Commons and Population Health: The State’s Intervention in an Individual’s Actions and Choices from a Capability Perspective

Externalities, scarcity, and abundance

Research on Rural Environmental Issues of China from the View of "the Tragedy of the Commons"

Behavioural Patterns Behind the Demise of the Commons Across Different Cultures.

Commons Organizing: Embedding Common Good and Institutions for Collective Action. Insights from Ethics and Economics