Abstract:In the early 1970s, we and others in the economics profession became enamored with the notion of externalties—a cost or benefit imposed on or provided to others but not taken into account by the economic agents who generate the effect. We, and others, seemed to see external effects everywhere. There was polluted water and air, noise, urban blight, traffic congestion, and other features of modern life that seemed to call out for some form of corrective action. As the externalities revolution unfolded, economists and other social scientists overlooked the importance of evolved legal and other institutions that formally and informally establish property and liability rules that cause decision makers to face the cost of their actions, including what otherwise could be external costs imposed on unwilling third parties. While markets seemed always to fail, political institutions were seen systematically as without blemish, or so it seemed. It was this two-pronged failure, 1) a failure to consider and state assumptions about background institutional arrangements and 2) a disregard for special interest politics, that became the Achilles Heel of the otherwise elegant externality arguments. Eventually, it was the modern institutionalists, scholars who focused on laws, regulation, and rules of the marketplace, who attempted to close the lid and drive the nails on the externality coffin. In this paper, we reach back to 1920 and trace the rise and decline of the policy importance of externalities theory. Beginning with A. C. Pigou and Alfred Marshall, our story includes some of the great figures in economic history of thought. But while theory was being built, institutions were overlooked. Pigou continues to be a dominant player in the story until the 1960s and 1970s when externalities theory was challenged by James M. Buchanan, Ronald Coase and other scholars. It is here in the twilight years of the externalities revolution that the prospects of government failure are raised as being more daunting than the likelihood of market failure. Finally, in the late 1970s and beyond, the externalities revolution is replaced by a property rights revolution.

Framing Institutional Choice, 1937–1973: New Institutional Economics and the Neglect of the Commons

Tragedy of the Commons after 50 Years

Pursuing a Grand Theory: Douglass C. North and the early making of a New Institutional Social Science (1950-1981)

Institutions and Economic Theory

The Diversity and Rapprochement of Theories of Institutional Change: Original Institutionalism and New Institutional Economics

Assessing the Potential of New Institutional Economics to Explain Institutional Change: the Case of Road Management Liberalization in the Nordic Countries

Between Commons and Anticommons: a Nested Common-Private Interface Framework

Commons Organizing: Embedding Common Good and Institutions for Collective Action. Insights from Ethics and Economics

Three approaches to institutions in economic analysis: Polanyi, North and the surplus approach's third way

Institutional Change in Advanced Political Economies

From public finance to public economics

Property Rights Problems in Agricultural Cooperatives: A Heterodox Institutionalist Perspective

A Model of Enclosures: Coordination, Conflict, and Efficiency in the Transformation of Land Property Rights

Economics with(out) ethics? An interdisciplinary encounter between public economists and John Rawls in the 1970s

THE END OF THE EXTERNALITY REVOLUTION

Competing Paradigms or Birds of a Feather? Constructivism and Neoliberal Institutionalism Compared

Externalities, scarcity, and abundance

The three institutionalisms and institutional dynamics: understanding endogenous and exogenous change

Polycentric and resilient perspectives for governing the commons: Strategic and law and economics insights for sustainable development

Institutionalism and New Trade Theory: Rethinking Comparative Advantage and Trade Policy

Innovation, institutions and development: a critical review and grounded heterodox economic analysis of late-industrialising contexts