Abstract:BACKGROUND: Clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) have become central to efforts to change clinical practice and improve the quality of health care. Despite growing attention for rigorous development methodologies, it remains unclear what contribution CPGs make to quality improvement.AIM: This mixed methods study examines guideline quality in relation to the availability of certain types of evidence and reflects on the implications of CPGs' promise to improve the quality of care practices.METHODS: The quality of 62 CPGs was assessed with the Appraisal of Guidelines, Research, and Evaluation (AGREE) instrument. Findings were discussed in 19 follow-up interviews to examine how different quality aspects were considered during development.RESULTS: The AGREE assessment showed that while some quality criteria were met, CPGs have limited coverage of domains such as stakeholder involvement and applicability, which generally lack a 'strong' evidence base (e.g., randomized controlled trials [RCT]). Qualitative findings uncovered barriers that impede the consolidation of evidence-based guideline development and quality improvement including guideline scoping based on the patient-intervention-comparison-outcome (PICO) question format and a lack of clinical experts involved in evidence appraisal. Developers used workarounds to include quality considerations that lack a strong base of RCT evidence, which often ended up in separate documents or appendices.CONCLUSION: Findings suggest that CPGs mostly fail to integrate different epistemologies needed to inform the quality improvement of clinical practice. To bring CPGs closer to their promise, guideline scoping should maintain a focus on the most pertinent quality issues that point developers toward the most fitting knowledge for the question at hand, stretching beyond the PICO format. To address questions that lack a strong evidence base, developers actually need to appeal to other sources of knowledge, such as quality improvement, expert opinion, and best practices. Further research is needed to develop methods for the robust inclusion of other types of knowledge.

A Model for Developing Evidence-Based Clinical Practice Guidelines for School Nursing

Evidence-Based Nursing based on Clinical Practice Guideline：practice and reflection

Methods for Developing Neuroscience Nursing Clinical Practice Guidelines

Introducing NASN's School Nursing Evidence-Based Clinical Practice Guideline: Allergy and Anaphylaxis CPG and Implementation Toolkit

Developing evidence-based practice guidelines and pathways: the experience at the local hospital level

Evidence‐basing for quality improvement; bringing clinical practice guidelines closer to their promise of improving care practices

Development and Implementation of Clinical Practice Guidelines: An Update and Synthesis of the Literature With a Focus in Application to Spinal Conditions

A model for adapting clinical guidelines for electronic implementation in primary care

Clinical guidelines: grading the evidence behind the practice

Exploring on Nursing Educational Innovation with Best Practice Guidelines to Cultivate Evidence-Informed Practice

Nursing practice of guidelines for prevention and control of vascular Catheter‐Related bloodstream infections

Evidence-Based Nursing models: focusing on the process of evidence-based practice

Elements Supporting Translation of Evidence Into Practice: A Model for Clinical Nurse Specialist and Nurse Scientist Collaboration

Critical Appraisal of Evidence for DNP-Prepared Nurses

CME CLINICAL COMMENTARY REVIEW: Patient Centered Practice Guidelines: GRADEing Evidence to Incorporate Certainty, Balance Between Benefits and Harms, Equity, Feasibility, and Cost-Effectiveness

Skills and Attributes Required by Clinical Nurse Specialists to Promote Evidence-Based Practice

Clinical application of the evidence-based clinical nursing guideline for nasogastric tube feeding

Teaching Evidence-Based Practice Competencies to Meet Professional Practice Needs

Refining and validating a conceptual model of Clinical Nurse Leader integrated care delivery

Integration of Evidence into a Detailed Clinical Model-based Electronic Nursing Record System

The research progress of Evidence-Based Nursing models: focusing on the essence of Evidence-Based Practice