On the selection of an empirical material constitutive model for the finite element modeling of Ti6Al4V orthogonal cutting, including the segmented chip formation

F. Ducobu,P.-J. Arrazola,E. Rivière-Lorphèvre,E. Filippi
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12289-020-01535-2
2020-01-29
International Journal of Material Forming
Abstract:Finite element modeling of machining aims for guidance in the choice of the cutting parameters and for the comprehension of the involved phenomena. The modeling of the behavior of the machined material is a key parameter to develop a realistic model. It is nowadays still extremely difficult to acquire experimental data on the material flow stress due to the extreme conditions encountered during machining. Many constitutive models are found in the literature and there is a lack of objective information to choose the best suited for a given application. Four empirical constitutive models are used in this paper to represent the Ti6Al4V titanium alloy during an orthogonal cutting operation. All of them are based on the well-known Johnson-Cook model. The results of this study show that the influence of the constitutive model on the chip morphology and on the cutting force is high and that the strain softening phenomenon should be taken into account to produce a segmented (or saw-toothed) chip as it is experimentally observed. For the cutting conditions adopted, adding damage properties in the chip is moreover required to obtain a morphology close to the experimental reference. All these elements allow to get a reliable numerical model able to reproduce cutting forces and chip morphology (either continuous or segmented) for various cutting conditions.
materials science, multidisciplinary,metallurgy & metallurgical engineering,engineering, manufacturing
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to select an appropriate material constitutive model in finite element modeling to accurately simulate the behavior of Ti6Al4V titanium alloy during orthogonal cutting, especially the phenomenon of segmented (or serrated) chip formation. Specifically, the research aims to: 1. **Evaluate the influence of different constitutive models on cutting force and chip morphology**: By comparing four constitutive models based on the Johnson - Cook model (JC, TANH, TANH2 and Sima), study their performance in simulating chip morphology and cutting force during the orthogonal cutting process of Ti6Al4V titanium alloy. 2. **Consider the strain - softening phenomenon**: The research points out that under high - strain conditions, the strain - softening phenomenon is crucial for the formation of segmented chips. Therefore, the paper explores the performance of different constitutive models when considering the strain - softening phenomenon. 3. **Introduce damage characteristics to improve model accuracy**: In order to more realistically simulate chip formation, the research introduces damage characteristics into the chip to observe their influence on chip morphology and cutting force. 4. **Provide an objective basis for model selection**: By comparing with experimental data, the research aims to provide objective information for future research and help select the most suitable constitutive model for specific applications. ### Research Background - **Material Characteristics**: Ti6Al4V titanium alloy is widely used in the aerospace and biomedical fields because of its high strength, fatigue resistance, corrosion resistance and good biocompatibility. - **Cutting Challenges**: Ti6Al4V is a difficult - to - machine material. Due to its low thermal conductivity and hardening characteristics, the extreme conditions (high strain, high strain rate and high temperature) during the cutting process make it very difficult to obtain experimental data. - **Importance of Finite Element Modeling**: Finite element modeling can help understand the complex phenomena during the cutting process and guide the selection of appropriate cutting parameters. ### Research Methods - **Experimental Reference**: Orthogonal cutting experiments are carried out using a standard milling machine to obtain experimental data as a reference. - **Numerical Model**: A two - dimensional plane - strain explicit Lagrangian orthogonal cutting model is established using ABAQUS/Explicit software to simulate the cutting process. - **Constitutive Model**: Compare four constitutive models based on the Johnson - Cook model (JC, TANH, TANH2 and Sima), which consider different strain - softening and temperature effects respectively. ### Main Findings - **Chip Morphology**: All four constitutive models without considering damage characteristics cannot accurately simulate the formation of segmented chips. Among them, the results of the TANH and Sima models are closer to the experimental data, but the differences are still significant. - **Cutting Force**: Different constitutive models have a significant impact on cutting force. The cutting force value of the Sima model is closest to the experimental data, with an error of 12%. - **Importance of Strain - Softening**: The strain - softening phenomenon is crucial for the formation of segmented chips, and temperature also affects the occurrence of this phenomenon. ### Conclusions - **Model Selection**: Under the condition of not considering damage characteristics, the TANH and Sima models perform better, but still need further improvement. - **Importance of Damage Characteristics**: Introducing damage characteristics can significantly improve the accuracy of the model and better simulate the formation of segmented chips. - **Future Research Directions**: It is necessary to further study the influence of the metallurgical state of the material on the parameters of the constitutive model and develop more accurate constitutive models to adapt to different cutting conditions. Through these studies, the paper provides important theoretical and practical guidance for the orthogonal cutting process of Ti6Al4V titanium alloy.