Comparative analysis of critical micelle concentration of cationic surfactants determined by conductivity, sound velocity, and density using weighted orthogonal distance regression
Luís M.S. Silva,Juan J. Galan-Díaz
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.surfin.2024.105620
IF: 6.2
2024-12-18
Surfaces and Interfaces
Abstract:In this study, three techniques - conductimetry, densitometry, and sound velocity measurement – were employed to determine the critical micelle concentration (CMC) of four cationic surfactants, namely dodecyl and tetradecyl pyridinium, in the presence of two halogen counterions, chloride and bromide. To this end, segmented regression was employed using a nonlinear optimization solver, to identify the breakpoint of the two linear segments and their respective parameters when the physical property was plotted against the surfactant concentration. The x-coordinate of the breakpoint is indicative of the CMC. The nonlinear problem formulated in this study was found to be accurate, with CMC estimations that were in close agreement with those reported in the literature.Considering the standard error of the CMC determined by the three techniques, it was concluded that the CMC estimated by conductivity was the most reliable and was therefore selected as the reference. The results of the weighted orthogonal distance regression analysis indicate that there are statistically significant differences between the CMC values obtained by conductivity, density, and sound velocity techniques. However, no conclusions can be drawn about the C 14 alkyl chain due to the uncertainties associated with the CMC assessments based on sound velocity and density. Furthermore, the CMC dependence with temperature becomes less evident with an increase in the chain length, which hinders the positive validation of the statistical correlation between CMCs. Furthermore, the influence of the counterion cannot be discounted. Alkyl pyridinium bromide exhibits a diminished temperature influence on CMC in comparison to the homologous chloride, which renders it more challenging to correlate the CMC estimated by density or even sound velocity against the reference CMC value predicted by conductimetry.To overcome the difficulties inherent in estimating the CMC based on density and sound velocity, an alternative technique that combines the simultaneous readings of these properties is proposed. The CMC of dodecylpyridinium chloride estimated by the breakpoint density coordinate of the specific gravity versus sound velocity plot shows better agreement with the CMC estimated by conductivity, with a mean relative difference of 7.90 %, than by the classical method with a mean relative difference of 12.9 %.
chemistry, physical,physics, applied, condensed matter,materials science, coatings & films