Young GI angle: Why and how to write a good review article
Gerhard Jung
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/2050640620926818
2020-06-01
United European Gastroenterology Journal
Abstract:Review articles aim to give an overview of the current scientific knowledge on a specific topic and are an important element of evidence-based medicine. Technically, review articles do not generate new data, but rather identify, structure, evaluate and summarize the evidence of existing primary research studies.<sup><a class="ref showRefEvent2" href="#">1</a></sup> While narrative review articles usually apply a less stringent methodology and present a broader scope of a topic, systematic reviews aim to answer precisely a specific scientific question by synthesizing the available evidence qualitatively and, whenever possible, quantitatively as meta-analyses, which requires profound methodological knowledge and skills in statistics. Narrative and systematic elements (with or without meta-analysis) can also be combined in one article.<sup><a class="ref showRefEvent2" href="#">2</a></sup> In any case, review articles tend to be of high quality, basically for two reasons: first, since they reach out to a broader audience and their visibility is more long-lasting compared with fast-moving original studies, authors and publishers want to ensure they do not lose their reputation. And second, they are usually written by either experts of a certain field or by researchers who are specifically dedicated to, and have a high level of expertise in, conducting systematic reviews and meta-analyses. At the same time, writing a review article comes with a considerable burden of responsibility because they shape future research.<sup><a class="ref showRefEvent2" href="#">1</a></sup> For instance, where evidence is scarce, review articles can create awareness of an unmet need to start up new projects. In other fields, evidence can be so abundant that it has become nearly impossible for researchers to read and appraise all available studies, and review articles are a welcomed source to understand current evidence with a reasonable effort of time.
gastroenterology & hepatology