Financial Innovation, Regulation and Crises in History ed. by Piet Clement, Harold James, and Herman Van der Wee (review)
D. Forsyth
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1353/ENS.2015.0015
2015-09-24
Abstract:argument that the author inverts. Moreover, in the absence of quantitative economic analysis, the relative importance of trade conducted by intimate networks as compared with that of the WIC remains an open question. Building on her sedulous detective work in the archival and printed sources, Romney’s close attention to New Netherland allows for remarkably detailed depiction of a range of micro-level relationships. This focus, however, also entails neglect of broader contexts, not only regarding other Dutch colonies and long-distance commerce but also concerning other European trade and imperial ventures of the time. A few of these issues are raised in footnotes, and some scholarship is critically, though briefl y, evaluated there. Had that material been integrated into the text, however, it could have been more adequately examined and perhaps helped nuance some of the author’s balder assertions (not to mention enhancing the book’s readability). New Netherland Connections provides much food for thought both for specialists in Dutch and Dutch colonial history and for students of empire and commerce throughout the early modern Atlantic. Thanks to Romney’s research, they will want to place in comparative perspective her theses on the important role that popular participation played in local and long-distance trade, in intercommunal relations, and in the circumstances in which colonial slavery could be modifi ed, if not evaded. It may then be possible to judge the degree to which the fascinating stories that the author has uncovered were unique to the Dutch Atlantic—or even to New Netherland—and how much they were rooted in the early stages of European colonization and global commerce.
History,Political Science