Speech Audiometry at Home: Automated Listening Tests via Smart Speakers With Normal-Hearing and Hearing-Impaired Listeners

Jasper Ooster,Melanie Krueger,Jörg-Hendrik Bach,Kirsten C. Wagener,Birger Kollmeier,Bernd T. Meyer
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/2331216520970011
2020-01-01
Trends in Hearing
Abstract:Speech audiometry in noise based on sentence tests is an important diagnostic tool to assess listeners’ speech recognition threshold (SRT), i.e., the signal-to-noise ratio corresponding to 50% intelligibility. The clinical standard measurement procedure requires a professional experimenter to record and evaluate the response (expert-conducted speech audiometry). The use of automatic speech recognition enables self-conducted measurements with an easy-to-use speech-based interface. This article compares self-conducted SRT measurements using smart speakers with expert-conducted laboratory measurements. With smart speakers, there is no control over the absolute presentation level, potential errors from the automated response logging, and room acoustics. We investigate the differences between highly controlled measurements in the laboratory and smart speaker-based tests for young normal-hearing (NH) listeners as well as for elderly NH, mildly and moderately hearing-impaired listeners in low, medium, and highly reverberant room acoustics. For the smart speaker setup, we observe an overall bias in the SRT result that depends on the hearing loss. The bias ranges from +0.7 dB for elderly moderately hearing-impaired listeners to +2.2 dB for young NH listeners. The intrasubject standard deviation is close to the clinical standard deviation (0.57/0.69 dB for the young/elderly NH compared with 0.5 dB observed for clinical tests and 0.93/1.09 dB for the mild/moderate hearing-impaired listeners compared with 0.9 dB). For detecting a clinically elevated SRT, the speech-based test achieves an area under the curve value of 0.95 and therefore seems promising for complementing clinical measurements.
otorhinolaryngology,audiology & speech-language pathology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is: how to achieve automated speech audiometry in the home environment through smart speakers, especially to measure the Speech Recognition Threshold (SRT), that is, the signal - to - noise ratio required to reach 50% comprehension in noise. Specifically, the research aims to evaluate the reliability and accuracy of self - testing using smart speakers and compare it with the professional test results in the laboratory environment. ### Key issues: 1. **Early diagnosis of the hearing - impaired population**: Traditional speech audiometry requires professional experimenters to record and evaluate the responses of subjects, which limits its popularity. Smart speakers can achieve self - testing through the voice interface, improving the accessibility and convenience of the test. 2. **Applicability to individuals with different hearing levels**: The research examined the applicability of smart speaker tests to young normal - hearing individuals, elderly normal - hearing individuals, and those with mild and moderate hearing impairments, especially under different room acoustic conditions. 3. **Reliability of the automated speech recognition system**: Smart speakers rely on the Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) system to record the responses of subjects. The research evaluated the accuracy and potential errors of this system under different conditions. ### Research methods: - **Testing tools**: Use the German matrix sentence test OLSA as a basis, which is a widely - used speech audiometry tool. - **Testing environment**: Three rooms with different acoustic conditions (living room, ordinary classroom, concert hall) were simulated in the laboratory to evaluate the influence of different acoustic environments on the test results. - **Subject grouping**: Include four groups of subjects: young normal - hearing individuals, elderly normal - hearing individuals, those with mild hearing impairments, and those with moderate hearing impairments. - **Data comparison**: Compare the test results of smart speakers with the professional test results in the laboratory, and analyze the differences and consistencies between the two. ### Main findings: - The smart speaker test results showed an overall deviation, which depends on the degree of hearing loss, ranging from + 0.7 dB (elderly with moderate hearing impairment) to + 2.2 dB (young normal - hearing individuals). - The within - group standard deviation of subjects with different hearing levels is close to the clinical standard deviation, indicating that the smart speaker test has a certain degree of reliability. - Through ROC curve analysis, the smart speaker test showed high accuracy in detecting clinically elevated SRT (AUC value of 0.95), showing its potential as a supplementary tool for clinical tests. In conclusion, this research demonstrates the feasibility and potential of smart speakers for speech audiometry in the home environment, especially in the early screening of hearing loss, and is expected to lower the threshold for the provision of hearing - aid devices.