Of plots and plantations, wilderness and frontiers in The City after Property
Nathan McClintock Centre Urbanisation Culture Société,Institut National de la Recherche Scientifique (INRS),Montréal,Québec,Canada
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02723638.2024.2328400
IF: 3.8
2024-06-12
Urban Geography
Abstract:On a July day in a Detroit living room just over a decade ago, a 97-year-old Grace Lee Boggs sat sharing her theories of revolutionary change with a dozen or so activists and scholars sitting in a semi-circle at her feet. At one point, Boggs tells them, "We have brains that can move from the concrete to the abstract. The key is always to return to the concrete" (quoted in Safransky, Citation 2023 , p. 174). While this pithy bit of advice was intended to guide community organizing strategies, it also clearly served as inspiration for Sara Safransky ( Citation 2023 ) as she crafted The City after Property , a magisterial work of urban geography. The book is a fluid and remarkable conversation between the concrete and the abstract, between the empirical and the theoretical, between the streets of Detroit and debates in the critical social sciences. ions such as racial capitalism, property regimes, and sustainability fixes, among others, are grounded through thick description and rich ethnographic detail, drawn from interviews and archives. That the author is present throughout, not as a disembodied academic voice, but as a real human on the ground, a keen observer, an interlocutor, often a participant, helps to further this dialog between the concrete and the abstract. We are privy in these moments to the unfolding of Safransky's thoughts as she tries to make sense of postindustrial Detroit, her geographic imagination taking hold in response to her observations of the (often literal) concrete, of the weeds pushing up between the cracks, of the tone or register of someone's voice. Safransky's narrative voice is reflexive but not self-conscious as she works to untangle several questions she lays out in the prologue (p. xv ): of urban land and property, race and personhood, abandonment and belonging, reckoning and healing in Detroit.
urban studies,geography