Abstract:Aim/Purpose: The research reported here aims to demonstrate a method by which novel applications of qualitative data in quantitative research can resolve ceiling effect tensions for educational and psychological research. Background: Self-report surveys and scales are essential to graduate education and social science research. Ceiling effects reflect the clustering of responses at the highest response categories resulting in non-linearity, a lack of variability which inhibits and distorts statistical analyses. Ceiling effects in stress reported by students can negatively impact the accuracy and utility of the resulting data. Methodology: A longitudinal sample example from graduate engineering students’ stress, open-ended critical events, and their early departure from doctoral study considerations demonstrate the utility and improved accuracy of adjusted stress measures to include open-ended critical event responses. Descriptive statistics are used to describe the ceiling effects in stress data and adjusted stress data. The longitudinal stress ratings were used to predict departure considerations in multilevel modeling ANCOVA analyses and demonstrate improved model predictiveness. Contribution: Combining qualitative data from open-ended responses with quantitative survey responses provides an opportunity to reduce ceiling effects and improve model performance in predicting graduate student persistence. Here, we present a method for adjusting stress scale responses by incorporating coded critical events based on the Taxonomy of Life Events, the application of this method in the analysis of stress responses in a longitudinal data set, and potential applications. Findings: The resulting process more effectively represents the doctoral student experience within statistical analyses. Stress and major life events significantly impact engineering doctoral students’ departure considerations. Recommendations for Practitioners: Graduate educators should be aware of students’ life events and assist students in managing graduate school expectations while maintaining progress toward their degree. Recommendation for Researchers: Integrating coded open-ended qualitative data into statistical models can increase the accuracy and representation of the lived student experience. The new approach improves the accuracy and presentation of students’ lived experiences by incorporating qualitative data into longitudinal analyses. The improvement assists researchers in correcting data with ceiling effects for use in longitudinal analyses. Impact on Society: The method described here provides a framework to systematically include open-ended qualitative data in which ceiling effects are present. Future Research: Future research should validate the coding process in similar samples and in samples of doctoral students in different fields and master’s students.

The Impact of Graduate Education on the Mental Complexity of Mid-Career Military Officers

Cultivating well-being in engineering graduate students through mindfulness training

Through many doors at once: rethinking the multiverse of graduate student professional development

The Influence of a Master’s Degree on the Socialization of Two Physical Education Professionals

How Perceptions of Obstacles, Stress, and Different Mindsets May Impact a Student’s Self-Beliefs

Effects of the MINDSTRONG© CBT-based program on depression, anxiety and healthy lifestyle behaviors in graduate health sciences students

Graduate student diversity, equity and inclusion professional development

Examining the Perception of Military Culture in the Undergraduate University Classroom

Effects of matching personal and organizational mindsets on belonging and organizational interest.

Using design thinking to improve psychological interventions: The case of the growth mindset during the transition to high school.

Six Years Up: Applied Sport Psychologists Surviving (and Thriving) after Graduation

Emerging Adults in the Military and College: An Examination of Group Differences in Identity Development, Transdiagnostic Processes, and Attitudes Toward Risk and Suicide

Growth mindset intervention among French university students, and its articulation with proactive coping strategies

Qualitative evaluation of a multidisciplinary master of cancer sciences: impacts on graduates and influencing curricular factors

A growth-theory-of-interest intervention increases interest in math and science coursework among liberal arts undergraduates.

Mitigating Ceiling Effects in a Longitudinal Study of Doctoral Engineering Student Stress and Persistence

Metacognition gains in public health graduate students following in-class peer evaluation

Impact of a Mindfulness-Based Intervention on Basic Psychological Need Satisfaction and Internalized Symptoms in Elementary School Students With Severe Learning Disabilities: Results From a Randomized Cluster Trial

To What Extent and Under Which Circumstances Are Growth Mind-Sets Important to Academic Achievement? Two Meta-Analyses

Shooter ready? Integrating mental skills training in an advanced sniper course

A review to characterise and map the growth mindset theory in health professions education