Abstract:Introduction: Professional identity formation (PIF) is an ongoing, self-reflective process involving habits of thinking, feeling and acting like a physician and is an integral component of medical education. While qualitative work has suggested that PIF is informed by professionalism, resilience, and leadership, there is a dearth of quantitative work in this area. Multiple methods build rigor and the present study aimed to quantitatively assess the relative psychometric contributions of professionalism, resilience, and leadership constructs to informing PIF, using a latent factor analysis approach. Methods: We analyzed data from the PILLAR study, which is an online cross-sectional assessment of a pre-clinical cohort of medical students in the RCSI University of Medicine and Health Sciences, Dublin, using established and validated quantitative measures in each area of interest: PIF, professionalism, leadership and resilience. A total of 76 items, combining four validated scales, along with a selection of demographic questions, were used. The hypothesis that PIF is informed by, and correlates with, professionalism, resilience and leadership was examined by conducting a confirmatory factor analysis of a proposed three-factor higher-order model. Model estimation used Maximum Likelihood Method (MLM) with geomin rotation. The hypothesized (measurement) model was examined against an alternative (saturated) model, as well as a three-factor model. Results: Latent variable analysis from 1,311 students demonstrated that a three-factor higher-order model best fit the data; suggesting PIF is informed by professionalism, resilience, and leadership, and that these constructs are statistically distinct and account for differential aspects of PIF. This higher-order model of PIF outperformed both the saturated model and the three-factor model. The analysis of which component may be the most or least influential was inconclusive, and the overall model was not influenced by year of training. Discussion: Building upon existing conceptual contentions, our study is the first to quantitatively support the contribution of professionalism, resilience, and leadership to the development of professional identity, and to delineate the inter-relationships between PIF and these constructs. This information can be used by medical educators when designing curricula and educational strategies intended to enhance PIF. Future work should seek to assess the influence of these constructs longitudinally.

The Defining Issues Test and the Four Component Model: Contributions to professional education

Moral Judgement Development in Higher Education: Insights from the Defining Issues Test

Insights From the Defining Issues Test on Moral Reasoning Competencies Development in Community Pharmacists

Does Moral Education Improve Moral Judgment? A Meta-Analysis of Intervention Studies Using the Defining Issues Test

Moral rationality and intuition: An exploration of relationships between the Defining Issues Test and the Moral Foundations Questionnaire

“Intermediate” Concepts and the Connection to Moral Education

How not to evaluate a psychological measure: Rebuttal to criticism of the Defining Issues Test of moral judgment development by Curzer and colleagues

From Donders’ Dilemma to Objective Internal Assessment: How Experimental Developmental Psychology Can Contribute to Moral Education

Validity study using factor analyses on the Defining Issues Test-2 in undergraduate populations

Alchemy and beyond: Indexing the Defining Issues Test.

Evaluating moral reasoning in nursing education

Stages of moral judgment development: Applying item response theory to Defining Issues Test data

Measuring moral reasoning using moral dilemmas: evaluating reliability, validity, and differential item functioning of the behavioural defining issues test (bDIT)

Impact of the dedicated education unit teaching model on the perceived competencies and professional attributes of nursing students

Using the American Board of Internal Medicine's "Elements of Professionalism" for undergraduate ethics education

The impact of debrief models on self-efficacy within mental health simulation training: a quantitative analysis

Do professionalism, leadership, and resilience combine for professional identity formation? Evidence from confirmatory factor analysis

Moral Schemas and Tacit Judgement or How the Defining Issues Test is Supported by Cognitive Science

Towards a Definition of Distinction in Professionalism

Impact and Assessment of Research Integrity Teaching: A Systematic Literature Review

Evaluating interventions to improve ethical decision making in clinical practice: a review of the literature and reflections on the challenges posed