Abstract:Background: Collaborative learning is recognized as an effective learning tool in the classroom. In order to optimize the collaborative learning experience for children within a collaborative partnership, it is important to understand how to match the children by ability level, and whether assigning roles within these dyads is beneficial or not. Aims: The current study investigated the effect of partnering children with different task-specific abilities and assigning or not assigning helping roles within the dyads on the quality of talk used in a collaborative learning task. Sample: The participants in this study comprised 54 year 6 pupils from a Western Sydney government primary school (boys=26, girls=28). The ages ranged from 10 years 10 months to 12 years 4 months with a mean age of 11 years 4 months. Method: The children were formed into 27 single sex dyads of low-middle- and low-high-ability partnerships. In half of each of these dyads the higher ability partner was asked to help the lower ability partner, which was compared with just asking partners to work together. The quality of talk used by the dyads while working collaboratively on the problem-solving task was analysed using a language analysis framework developed by Mercer and colleagues (e.g. Littleton et al., 2005; Mercer, 1994, 1996). Results: Results of this study found that children who worked collaboratively in the low-middle-ability dyad condition demonstrated significantly more high-quality exploratory talk than those in the low-high-ability dyad condition. Although there was no significant difference between dyads who were assigned roles and those who were asked to work together, there was an interaction trend which suggests that low-high-ability dyads, who were given the roles of helper and learner, showed more exploratory talk than dyads who were asked just to work together. Conclusion: Mercer's re-conceptualization of Vygotsky's Zone of Proximal Development (ZPD) in terms of the Intermental Development Zone (IDZ), which is reliant on constructive challenging discourse, can potentially provide a platform upon which all learners in the classroom can benefit from collaborative learning experiences.

Peer assistance in children's problem solving

Towards effective partnerships in a collaborative problem-solving task

Cooperation Turns Preschoolers into Flexible Perspective Takers

Influence of a Playful, Child-Directed Context on Preschool Children’s Peer Cooperation

Does a peer model's task proficiency influence children's solution choice and innovation?

Collaboration promotes proportional reasoning about resource distribution in young children.

The Influence of Peer Interaction on Students' Creative Problem-Finding Ability

The role of collaboration in the cognitive development of young children: a systematic review

Peer Interaction Does Not Always Improve Children’s Mental State Talk Production in Oral Narratives. A Study in 6- to 10-Year-Old Italian Children

Peer–Peer Interaction between L2 Learners of Different Proficiency Levels: Their Interactions and Reflections

Can the Effect of Problem Solvers’ Characteristics on Adolescents’ Cooperative Problem Solving Ability Be Improved by Group Sizes?

Cooperation, but Not Competition, Improves 4-Year-old Children's Reasoning about Others' Diverse Desires.

Help-seeking: An understudied problem-solving skill in children

Collaborative reasoning in the context of group competition

What do children value more in a collaborator-Problem-solving capacity or fair sharing?

The Characteristics of Preschool Children’s Collaborative Problem Solving: A Discourse Analysis in Project-Based Learning

How do children with language disorder perceive their peer interactions? A qualitative investigation

Parents spontaneously scaffold the formation of conversational pacts with their children

Young Children's Ability to Produce Valid and Relevant Counter-Arguments

‘You hit me! That's not nice and it makes me sad!!’: relations of young children's social information processing and early school success

The Role of Child Characteristics and Peer Experiences in the Development of Peer Cooperation