Abstract:Mendelian randomization (MR) implemented through instrumental variables analysis is an increasingly popular causal inference tool used in genetic epidemiology. But it can have limitations for evaluating simultaneous causal relationships in complex data sets that include, for example, multiple genetic predictors and multiple potential risk factors associated with the same genetic variant. Here we use real and simulated data to investigate Bayesian network analysis (BN) with the incorporation of directed arcs, representing genetic anchors, as an alternative approach. A Bayesian network describes the conditional dependencies/independencies of variables using a graphical model (a directed acyclic graph) with an accompanying joint probability. In real data, we found BN could be used to infer simultaneous causal relationships that confirmed the individual causal relationships suggested by bi-directional MR, while allowing for the existence of potential horizontal pleiotropy (that would violate MR assumptions). In simulated data, BN with two directional anchors (mimicking genetic instruments) had greater power for a fixed type 1 error than bi-directional MR, while BN with a single directional anchor performed better than or as well as bi-directional MR. Both BN and MR could be adversely affected by violations of their underlying assumptions (such as genetic confounding due to unmeasured horizontal pleiotropy). BN with no directional anchor generated inference that was no better than by chance, emphasizing the importance of directional anchors in BN (as in MR). Under highly pleiotropic simulated scenarios, BN outperformed both MR (and its recent extensions) and two recently-proposed alternative approaches: a multi-SNP mediation intersection-union test (SMUT) and a latent causal variable (LCV) test. We conclude that BN incorporating genetic anchors is a useful complementary method to conventional MR for exploring causal relationships in complex data sets such as those generated from modern "omics" technologies.

Advances to Bayesian network inference for generating causal networks from observational biological data

JBigin: A Java Package for Bayesian Inference of Genetic Interaction Networks from Micro-Array Data

Learning Cluster Causal Diagrams: an Information-Theoretic Approach

CBN: Constructing a clinical Bayesian network based on data from the electronic medical record

Bayesian network analysis incorporating genetic anchors complements conventional Mendelian randomization approaches for exploratory analysis of causal relationships in complex data

Inferring Causal Protein Signalling Networks from Single-Cell Data Based on Parallel Discrete Artificial Bee Colony Algorithm

Discovering biomedical causality by a generative Bayesian causal network under uncertainty

Causal datasheet: An approximate guide to practically assess Bayesian networks in the real world

A Full Bayesian Approach to Sparse Network Inference Using Heterogeneous Datasets

Neural Bayesian Network Understudy

Bayesian Inference of Genetic Regulatory Networks from Time Series Microarray Data Using Dynamic Bayesian Networks

Causal network inference using biochemical kinetics

A Canonical Correlation Analysis-Based Dynamic Bayesian Network Prior to Infer Gene Regulatory Networks from Multiple Types of Biological Data

High-Dimensional Bayesian Network Inference From Systems Genetics Data Using Genetic Node Ordering

Application of Bayesian Networks on Large-Scale Biological Data

Inference of Gene Regulatory Network Through Adaptive Dynamic Bayesian Network Modeling

Development of a graphical model of causal gene regulatory networks using medical big data and Bayesian machine learning

Bayesian Inference of Networks Across Multiple Sample Groups and Data Types

Inference of time-delayed gene regulatory networks based on dynamic Bayesian network hybrid learning method.

High-order dynamic Bayesian Network learning with hidden common causes for causal gene regulatory network

Dynamic Bayesian Network Learning to Infer Sparse Models From Time Series Gene Expression Data