Abstract:Background: COVID-19 is a new multi-organ disease causing considerable worldwide morbidity and mortality. While many recognized pathophysiological mechanisms are involved, their exact causal relationships remain opaque. Better understanding is needed for predicting their progression, targeting therapeutic approaches, and improving patient outcomes. While many mathematical causal models describe COVID-19 epidemiology, none have described its pathophysiology. Methods: In early 2020, we began developing such causal models. The SARS-CoV-2 virus's rapid and extensive spread made this particularly difficult: no large patient datasets were publicly available; the medical literature was flooded with sometimes conflicting pre-review reports; and clinicians in many countries had little time for academic consultations. We used Bayesian network (BN) models, which provide powerful calculation tools and directed acyclic graphs (DAGs) as comprehensible causal maps. Hence, they can incorporate both expert opinion and numerical data, and produce explainable, updatable results. To obtain the DAGs, we used extensive expert elicitation (exploiting Australia's exceptionally low COVID-19 burden) in structured online sessions. Groups of clinical and other specialists were enlisted to filter, interpret and discuss the literature and develop a current consensus. We encouraged inclusion of theoretically salient latent (unobservable) variables, likely mechanisms by extrapolation from other diseases, and documented supporting literature while noting controversies. Our method was iterative and incremental: systematically refining and validating the group output using one-on-one follow-up meetings with original and new experts. 35 experts contributed 126 hours face-to-face, and could review our products. Results: We present two key models, for the initial infection of the respiratory tract and the possible progression to complications, as causal DAGs and BNs with corresponding verbal descriptions, dictionaries and sources. These are the first published causal models of COVID-19 pathophysiology. Conclusions: Our method demonstrates an improved procedure for developing BNs via expert elicitation, which other teams can implement to model emergent complex phenomena. Our results have three anticipated applications: (i) freely disseminating updatable expert knowledge; (ii) guiding design and analysis of observational and clinical studies; (iii) developing and validating automated tools for causal reasoning and decision support. We are developing such tools for the initial diagnosis, resource management, and prognosis of COVID-19, parameterized using the ISARIC and LEOSS databases.

Development of a graphical model of causal gene regulatory networks using medical big data and Bayesian machine learning

From Genome-Scale Data to Models of Infectious Disease: A Bayesian Network-Based Strategy to Drive Model Development

CBN: Constructing a clinical Bayesian network based on data from the electronic medical record

Causal Inference and Counterfactual Prediction in Machine Learning for Actionable Healthcare

Interactive molecular causal networks of hypertension using a fast machine learning algorithm MRdualPC

Discovering biomedical causality by a generative Bayesian causal network under uncertainty

Modeling the causal mechanism between genotypes and phenotypes using large-scale biobank data and context-specific regulatory networks

Advances to Bayesian network inference for generating causal networks from observational biological data

Developing a novel causal inference algorithm for personalized biomedical causal graph learning using meta machine learning

Causal modeling in large-scale data to improve identification of adults at risk for combined and common variable immunodeficiencies

Causal machine learning for healthcare and precision medicine

Learning Causality: Synthesis of Large-Scale Causal Networks from High-Dimensional Time Series Data

Implicit Causal Models for Genome-wide Association Studies

Targeted Cause Discovery with Data-Driven Learning

Modeling COVID-19 disease processes by remote elicitation of causal Bayesian networks from medical experts

Reconstructing Molecular Networks by Causal Diffusion Do‐Calculus Analysis with Deep Learning

High-order dynamic Bayesian Network learning with hidden common causes for causal gene regulatory network

Causal Network Models for Predicting Compound Targets and Driving Pathways in Cancer.

Mining Causal Relationships among Clinical Variables for Cancer Diagnosis Based on Bayesian Analysis

Bayesian network analysis incorporating genetic anchors complements conventional Mendelian randomization approaches for exploratory analysis of causal relationships in complex data

Use of Bayesian networks to dissect the complexity of genetic disease: application to the Genetic Analysis Workshop 17 simulated data