Nephelinite-carbonatite liquid immiscibility at Shombole volcano, East Africa: Petrographic and experimental evidence

B. Kjarsgaard,T. Peterson
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/bf01164532
1991-05-01
Mineralogy and Petrology
Abstract:We summarize the evidence for silicate-carbonate liquid immiscibility in two nephelinite lavas from Shombole volcano, East Africa, and discuss its significance for carbonatite petrogenesis. The nephelinite lavas contain spherical to irregular globules ≤ 0.5 cm containing low-Sr calcite, Sr-Ca and K-Ba zeolites, fluorite, aegirine, strontianite, and fluorapatite. The globules are interpreted to be magmatic in origin, and represent quenched immiscible carbonate liquid. Most phases in the globules form an interlocking mosaic of euhedral crystals, however, rare blebby intergrowths of calcite and strontianite indicate eutectic crystallization from a melt. The phase assemblages and respective compositions of minerals in the globules and silicate groundmass are nearly identical, indicating that the samples were quenched when two liquids were in near-equilibrium. Experiments with the samples at 200–500 MPa and 975–925 °C have reproduced the natural assemblages (phenocrysts + 2 liquids) exactly and the compositions of experimentally generated solid phases closely match the original phenocrysts. The natural and experimentally produced carbonatites are both sövitic (calcite carbonatite) in composition.The two-liquid experimental data from Shombole are compared with the 300 MPa experimental data ofFreestone andHamilton (1980) andHamilton et al. (1989), who utilized strongly peralkaline bulk compositions typical of the lavas erupted at Oldoinyo Lengai. Both data sets are nearly coplanar in the tetrahedron Si-(Ca + Mg + Fe2+)-(Al + Fe3+)-(Na + K) (SCAN), but the tielines have different orientations and the Oldoinyo Lengai bulk compositions generate alkali-rich carbonatitic liquids, rather than sövitic liquids. At both volcanic centers, only one type of extrusive carbonatite is known, and crystal fractionation schemes to generate one carbonatite from another are not supported by the data. Experiments illustrate that the full range of Ca-Mg-(Na + K) carbonatites can be generated by liquid immiscibility from nephelinitic magmas of different compositions.
geochemistry & geophysics,mineralogy
What problem does this paper attempt to address?