Immiscibility of Carbonatitic and Alkaline Silicate Melts from an Evolved Ultramafic Magma: Titanite Geochronology and In-Situ Ti Nd Isotope Insights

Xiaojia Jiang,Xin Chen,Shaoyong Jiang,Liam Hoare,Wen Zhang,Dongyang Lian,Pengjie Cai,Yaoming Xu,Hong Liu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemgeo.2024.122433
IF: 3.9
2024-01-01
Chemical Geology
Abstract:Carbonatites and alkaline rocks often exhibit a close spatial association with Nb and rare earth elements (REE) mineralization. Petrological and experimental studies suggest that carbonated and alkaline silicate melts can be formed directly through low-degree partial melting of a carbonate-bearing mantle. Alternatively, some propose that fractional crystallization followed by liquid immiscibility from mantle-derived magmas could be a viable model for the formation of carbonatites and alkaline rocks. In this study, samples from ultramafic to alkaline rocks and carbonatites in the Shangzhuang P-REE deposit, Western China are analyzed to investigate this issue. The complexes consist of biotite clinopyroxenite, fluorapatite-rich biotite clinopyroxenite, and calcite-K-feldsparamphibole-rich clinopyroxenite, interspersed with minor syenite and carbonatite dykes. These suites of rocks exhibit similar ages and Nd isotopic characteristics, indicating their derivation from a common magma source. Field, petrological, geochemical, and Ti isotopic investigations reveal the parental ultramafic melts (with high Mg-#, low HFSE, and chondritic delta Ti-49 values) undergo a differentiation process into carbonate- and alkaline-rich ultramafic silicate melts (enriched in REEs, HFSE and Fe). These carbon- and alkaline-rich melts then formed immiscible carbonatitic- (high REE and negative delta Ti-49 values of -1.78 to -0.49 %o) and alkaline silicate-melts (high Nb and delta Ti-49 values of +0.18 to +0.62 %o). The enrichment of REE and Nb in the system is attributed to magmatic crystallization differentiation and subsequent liquid immiscibility. This process resulted in the enrichment of REE in carbonatites, whereas alkaline rocks show a higher enrichment in Nb. This study provides a possible mechanism to explain the genetic linkage between carbonatites and alkaline rocks that is likely applicable to similar rock suites worldwide.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?