Abstract:During visual imagination, a perceptual representation is activated in the absence of sensory input. This is sometimes described as seeing with the mind's eye. A number of physiological studies indicate that the brain uses more or less the same neural resources for visual perception of sensory information and visual imagination. The intensity of visual imagination is typically assessed with questionnaires, while more objective measures are missing. Aim of the present study was, to test a new experimental paradigm that may allow to objectively quantify imagination. For this, we used priming and adaptation effects during observation of ambiguous figures. Our perception of an ambiguous stimulus is unstable and alternates spontaneously between two possible interpretations. If we first observe an unambiguous stimulus variant (the conditioning stimulus), the subsequently presented ambiguous stimulus can either be perceived in the same way as the test stimulus (priming effect) or in the opposite way (adaptation effect) as a function of the conditioning time. We tested for these conditioning effects (priming and adaptation) using an ambiguous Necker Cube and an ambiguous Letter /Number stimulus as test stimuli and unambiguous variants thereof as conditioning stimuli. In a second experimental condition, we tested whether the previous imagination of an unambiguous conditioning stimulus variant – instead of its observation – can have similar conditioning effects on the subsequent test stimulus. We found no systematic conditioning effect on the group level, neither for the two stimulus types (Necker Cube stimuli and Letter /Number stimuli) nor for the two conditions (Real and Imaginary). However, significant correlations between effects of Real and Imaginary Condition were observed for both stimulus types. The absence of conditioning effects at the group level may be explained by using only one conditioning time, which may fit with individual priming and adaptation constants of some of our participants but not of others. Our strong correlation results indicate that observers with clear conditioning effects have about the same type (priming or adaptation) and intensity of imaginary conditioning effects. As a consequence, not only past perceptual experiences but also past imaginations can influence our current percepts. This is further confirmation that the mechanisms underlying perception and imagination are similar. Our post-hoc qualitative observations from three self-defined aphantasic observers indicate that our paradigm may be a promising objective measure to identify aphantasia.

The Medusa effect reveals levels of mind perception in pictures

The medium modulates the medusa effect: Perceived mind in analogue and digital images

Extracting Social Meaning from a Face: The Neural Substrates and Behavioral Repercussions of Mind Perception

The Medusa effect: a registered replication report of Will, Merritt, Jenkins and Kingstone (2021)

More than a body: Mind perception and the nature of objectification.

Mind’s Selective Attention to Previous Experience

Seeing the mind of robots: Harm augments mind perception but benevolent intentions reduce dehumanisation of artificial entities in visual vignettes.

Binocularly suppressed stimuli induce brain activities related to aesthetic emotions

Mind in the Machine: Perceived Minds Induce Decision Change

Mind Artist: Creating Artistic Snapshots with Human Thought

Visual features influence thought content in the absence of overt semantic information

Semantic Differential Scale Method Can Reveal Multi-Dimensional Aspects of Mind Perception

Neurocognitive Processing of Body Representations in Artistic and Photographic Images.

Non-invasive electrical brain stimulation modulates human conscious perception of mental representation

Instant Effects of Semantic Information on Visual Perception

Influence of mental imagery on spatial presence and enjoyment assessed in different types of media

An Electrophysiological Abstractness Effect for Metaphorical Meaning Making

A Robot by Any Other Frame: Framing and Behaviour Influence Mind Perception in Virtual but not Real-World Environments

Visual imagination can influence visual perception – towards an experimental paradigm to measure imagination

Reality and imagination intertwined: A sensorimotor paradox interpretation

Social perception of robots is shaped by beliefs about their minds