Abstract:Case studies have long been used to research and illuminate the lives of gifted students. One example is the longitudinal study of profoundly gifted students by the first author elaborating the impact of acceleration, non-acceleration, and ability grouping on gifted students academically, socially, and emotionally. In this chapter an overview of ability grouping and acceleration for academically gifted high school students in Australia in relation to their self-esteem will be reiterated. Specifically, a study will be discussed that examined the effects of three interventions: (1) ability grouping, (2) acceleration, and (3) acceleration used concurrently with ability grouping, on the self-esteem of academically gifted high school students. Self-esteem was assessed on three occasions during the school year with three groups of academically gifted Australian students undertaking their first year of secondary school (Year 7): (a) students in comprehensive schools (mixed-ability settings); (b) students in selective high schools (full-time ability grouping in schools serving only gifted students); and (c) students in selective high schools who were also collapsing Years 7 and 8 into a single year—a blend of ability grouping and acceleration. Students in the first two groups experienced a diminution (but not a serious drop) in self-esteem, probably associated with the drop-in status from being the most senior students in a (relatively) small primary school to being one of the youngest students in a school that could be several times larger. By contrast, students in the third group, which was not only experiencing the shift from primary to secondary school status but also telescoping the first two high school years into one, experienced only a modest dip in self-esteem. Their scores started off high and remained high. Some teachers in the schools employing the blend of acceleration and grouping expressed their concern that the use of two treatments rather than one might be ‘a bridge too far’. It does not seem to have been. Rather it seems to be an effective mode of blending two interventions whose effectiveness for supporting gifted students’ self-esteem is already acknowledged. Implications for research and practice that links with current research will be elaborated.

A decade of longitudinal research on academic acceleration through the study of mathematically precocious youth

Ten-year longitudinal follow-up of ability-matched accelerated and unaccelerated gifted students.

Academic acceleration in gifted youth and fruitless concerns regarding psychological well-being: A 35-year longitudinal study.

Exceptionally Gifted Children: Long-Term Outcomes of Academic Acceleration and Nonacceleration

The Efficacy of Academic Acceleration for Gifted Minority Students

Academic Acceleration: Is it Right for My Child?

Early Math Coursework and College Readiness: Evidence from Targeted Middle School Math Acceleration

Method considerations for school psychology from longitudinal research on gifted students

Practitioner Objections to the Academic Acceleration of Gifted Children

Put Them Together and See How They Learn! Ability Grouping and Acceleration Effects on the Self-Esteem of Academically Gifted High School Students

Lessons from the Field: Examining the Challenges and Successes of a Mathematics and Science Program Using Acceleration and Enrichment for Gifted Urban Middle School Students

What Boosts Talent Development? Examining Predictors of Academic Growth in Secondary School Among Academically Advanced Youth Across 21 Years

Applying Frasier Four A’s to Promote Upstander Teachers for Academic Acceleration of Gifted Black Students

Predicting Marginalized Students' Mathematics Achievement in High School

A latent growth moderated mediation model of math achievement and postsecondary attainment: Focusing on context-invariant predictors.

Social Coping Among Academically Gifted Adolescents in a Residential Setting: A Longitudinal Study

An Investigation of an Early College Entrance Program’s Ability to Impact Intellectual and Social Development

Growth in Mathematics Achievement: Analysis With Classification and Regression Trees

What Longitudinal Research and Large-Scale Population Representative Studies Can Tell Us About Gifted Students and Education Policy 50 Years After the Marland Report

A Longitudinal Study of Academic Intrinsic Motivation in Intellectually Gifted Children: Childhood Through Early Adolescence

Mindsets, contexts, and college enrollment: Taking the long view on growth mindset beliefs at the transition to high school