Abstract:Abstract Artificial intelligence in higher education is becoming more prevalent as it promises improvements and acceleration of administrative processes concerning student support, aiming for increasing student success and graduation rates. For instance, Academic Performance Prediction (APP) provides individual feedback and serves as the foundation for distributing student support measures. However, the use of APP with all its challenges (e.g., inherent biases) significantly impacts the future prospects of young adults. Therefore, it is important to weigh the opportunities and risks of such systems carefully and involve affected students in the development phase. This study addresses students’ fairness perceptions of the distribution of support measures based on an APP system. First, we examine how students evaluate three different distributive justice norms, namely, equality , equity , and need . Second, we investigate whether fairness perceptions differ between APP based on human or algorithmic decision-making, and third, we address whether evaluations differ between students studying science, technology, engineering, and math (STEM) or social sciences, humanities, and the arts for people and the economy (SHAPE), respectively. To this end, we conducted a cross-sectional survey with a 2 $$\times$$ × 3 factorial design among n = 1378 German students, in which we utilized the distinct distribution norms and decision-making agents as design factors. Our findings suggest that students prefer an equality-based distribution of support measures, and this preference is not influenced by whether APP is based on human or algorithmic decision-making. Moreover, the field of study does not influence the fairness perception, except that students of STEM subjects evaluate a distribution based on the need norm as more fair than students of SHAPE subjects. Based on these findings, higher education institutions should prioritize student-centric decisions when considering APP, weigh the actual need against potential risks, and establish continuous feedback through ongoing consultation with all stakeholders.

Classroom justice: Perceptions of fairness as a predictor of student motivation, learning, and aggression

EFL/ESL Students' Perceptions of Distributive, Procedural, and Interactional Justice: The Impact of Positive Teacher-Student Relation

Distributive Justice and Higher Education Resource Allocation: Perceptions of Fairness

Do Perceptions of Legitimacy and Fairness Matter in Prison? Examining How Procedural and Distributive Justice Relate to Misconduct

Teachers' legitimacy: Effects of justice perception and social comparison processes

The Influence of Individual and Situational Factors on Teachers’ Justice Ratings of Classroom Interactions

The Impact of Affect on Organizational Justice Perceptions: A Test of the Affect Infusion Model

Fairness of Academic Performance Prediction for the Distribution of Support Measures for Students: Differences in Perceived Fairness of Distributive Justice Norms

Digital Module 33: Fairness in Classroom Assessment: Dimensions and Tensions

Effect of Organizational Justice on Job Outcomes: Mediating Role of Affective Commitment

Academic perspectives on metrics: procedural justice as a key factor in evaluations of fairness

Perceived Collective School Efficacy Mediates the Organizational Justice Effect in Teachers’ Subjective Well-Being

A fair share: Effects of disparity, allocation strategy and system justification on perceptions of policy support in the education domain

How do people judge fairness in supervisor and peer relationships? Another assessment of the dimensions of justice

Victimized Teachers' Perceptions of Procedural Justice and the Impact on Satisfaction with School Responses

Measuring Fairness and Justice in the Classroom: A Systematic Review of Instruments' Validity Evidence

Unfair teachers, unhappy students: longitudinal associations of perceived teacher relational unfairness with adolescent peer aggression and school satisfaction

The relationship between college students' belief in a just world and online prosocial behavior

Exploring the role of perception of social justice in predicting attitudes toward inclusive education for students with disabilities: a formative investigation of a theory

GENDER EQUALITY IS NOT ENOUGH: WHAT TEACHERS HAVE TAUGHT ME ABOUT JUSTICE?

Teachers' Conceptions of Fairness in Classroom Assessment: An Empirical Study