Abstract:Purpose As of 2022, the scope of the engagement and interest of debt capital providers in ESG reporting is mainly untapped. However, a vast amount of literature has produced conflicting findings about the importance of debt capital (leverage) as a factor in sustainability reporting (SR). This is the first meta-analysis reconciling the mixed results of 85 single country studies containing 131 effect sizes across 24,482 firms conducted over past three decades (1999–2022) investigating the influence of leverage on SR. The study emphasizes the significance of contextualizing research by identifying the macro-environmental elements modifying debt's impact on SR, through the use of the institutional theory. Eleven country variables were tested on the collected dataset, spread across 36 countries. Design/methodology/approach Meta-analysis technique for aggregation of existing extant empirical work. Continuous and categorical variable-based moderator analysis to demystify the influence of country characteristics affecting the leverage–SR relationship. Findings Results show positive significant impact of debt capital providers on SR. Country's level of development, GDP, extent of capital constraints in a country, financial sector development within a nation, country governance factors and corruption levels, country's culture, number of sustainability reporting instruments operational in a country and geographical location proved to be significant moderators. Research limitations/implications The study details relevant meaningful research gaps, worthy of uptake by researchers to produce targeted research. Practical implications Governments must increasingly go beyond their mandated disclosure role and acknowledge the important institutional factors that have contributed to the expansion of ESG reporting through the creation of nation-specific tools, incentive structures and disclosure-encouraging regulations. To secure a steady flow of funding and prevent negative effects on company value and cost of capital in the midst of prolonged global economic upheaval, businesses must address the information requirements of lenders. The limited total effect size emphasizes the necessity for debt providers to step up their ESG activism and exercise their maximum power and potential in stimulating extensive SR firm-level practices. Originality/value The present study is the first meta-analysis reconciling the mixed results of 85 single-country studies containing 131 effect sizes across 24,482 firms conducted over the past three decades (1999–2022) investigating the influence of leverage on SR and demystifying the macro-environmental factors affecting the leverage–SR association.

Where states and markets meet: the financialisation of sovereign debt management

The financialization of the state: Government debt management reforms in New Zealand and Ireland

Financialization of government debt? European government debt management approaches 1980–2007

The political economy of euro area sovereign debt restructuring

The Long-Term Use of Short-Term Debt Around the World

RESTRUCTURING DOMESTIC SOVEREIGN DEBT: FISCAL SAVINGS AND FINANCIAL STABILITY CONSIDERATIONS

Definancialization, financial repression and policy continuity in East-Central Europe

Assessing financialization under international financial subordination: a mixed-methods study of Brazilian and Turkish non-financial corporations

Sovereign Debt in the 21st Century

Sovereign debt management and the globalization of finance: Recasting the City of London’s ‘Big Bang’

The financial structure of government debt in OECD countries: An examination of the time-consistency issue

The International Dimensions of the Argentine Default: The Case of the Sovereign Debt Restructuring Mechanism

Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) Performance and Sovereign Bond Spreads: An Empirical Analysis of OECD Countries

Expanding the politics of measurement in sustainable finance: Reconceptualizing environmental, social and governance information as infrastructure

Impact of debt on sustainability reporting: a meta-analysis of the moderating role of country characteristics

Government Debt Management: The Long and the Short of It

Making the Eurozone Sustainable by Financial Engineering or Political Union?

Co-working in the collateral factory: analyzing the infrastructural entanglements of public debt management, central banking, and primary dealer systems

The rise of common public debt in Europe: a new chapter in fiscal integration?

Ties that bind and blur: financialization and the evolution of sovereign debt as private contract

The Costs and Consequences of Sovereign Borrowing