International Debt Sustainability Reconciling Debt Intolerance with Original Sin
J. N. Thornton
Abstract:In the recent literature on debt sustainability, two competing viewpoints have emerged addressing the underlying causes of many emerging market countries’ difficulty in sustaining their debt. Carmen Reinhart, Kenneth Rogoff, and Miguel Savastano, authors of the 2003 article “Debt Intolerance,” argue that institutional weaknesses, evidenced by histories of default and inflation, are the root causes of many countries’ inability to sustain advanced country levels of debt, or debt intolerance. On the other hand, Barry Eichengreen, Ricardo Hausmann, and Ugo Panizza, authors of the 2003 article “The Pain of Original Sin,” argue that while institutional history certainly matters, the nature of the international financial system plays a more important role. More specifically, they argue that original sin, or many countries’ inability to borrow externally in their own currency, takes a primary role in explaining debt intolerance. This paper attempts to reconcile the two views by showing that both institutional history and the incidence of original sin matter empirically when attempting to explain intolerance of external debt. The analysis contains two main analytical chapters: one in which long-term debt intolerance is explained through cross-sectional analysis, and another where year-to-year changes in debt intolerance are explained through panel analysis. In all of the paper, debt intolerance is proxied with measures of country risk such as credit ratings or sovereign bond interest rate spreads. The empirical work shows that once factors such as levels of external debt and whether the country is in an advanced country “club” are controlled for, both variables relating to a country’s default and inflation history and variables indicating its incidence of original sin are economically and statistically significant. Acknowledgements: First and foremost, I would like to thank my thesis advisor, Professor Ronald McKinnon, for his infinite support and patience. Without his guidance, this project would certainly not have been possible. I am also truly grateful to University of Maryland professor Carmen Reinhart for sharing much of her data with me. In addition, I would like to thank my major advisor, Professor David McKenzie for encouraging my interest in graduate school and thesis writing early on, and Professor Geoffrey Rothwell, director of the economics honors program, for his insight and humor. Finally, many thanks to my friends, my family, and especially my roommate for their patience and understanding during the long and at times arduous process of preparing this paper. Any remaining mistakes are solely attributable to the author.
Economics,Political Science