The Retailer' s Optimal Acquisition Strategy under Manufacturer' s Encroachment
HU Huaqing,GE Zehui,CHEN Lihua
DOI: https://doi.org/10.12005/orms.2023.0038
2023-01-01
Abstract:The Internet and e-commerce have been developing rapidly, which motivates manufacturers to introduce their own direct selling channels. There is a large body of research that investigates manufacturer’s channel operations strategy, but few studies examine retailers’ coping strategy under encroachment. Due to the retailers’ advantage in collecting consumer information, we study and put forward the optimal information acquisition strategy for the retailer facing encroachment. Considering the retailer’s flexibility in information acquisition timing, we focus on two formats, namely committed acquisition and contingent acquisition, depending on whether the retailer commits to her acquisition decision before or after the manufacturer’s quality investment. With contingent acquisition, the manufacturer first makes his product quality decision and then the retailer proceeds with her information acquisition decision. By contrast, with committed acquisition, the retailer moves first and decides whether to acquire information, and then the manufacturer invests in the product quality. Then, we investigate the manufacturer’s product quality decision and selling decision. In this study, we not only offer theoretical guidance for retailers to cope with encroachment, but also provide references for improving product quality and consumer’s expected utility. The results can be summarized as follows. First, the selling decisions of both the retailer and the manufacturer are affected by consumers’ preference and the manufacturer’s efficiency in direct selling. In particular, when consumers’ quality preference is low and direct sales efficiency is not high, there will be no sales in the manufacturer’s direct channel. However, when the manufacturer is efficient in direct selling, the retailer will be squeezed out of the reselling channel（i.e., there will be no sales in the reselling channel）. When the consumers’ quality preference is relatively high, the manufacturer will sell in both channels. Second, direct sales efficiency will affect the manufacturer’s sales decision and the product quality decisions. When direct sales efficiency is high, the manufacturer improves product quality in the product development stage to set a higher direct sales price. When the manufacturer is less efficient in direct selling, the manufacturer will reduce or even give up sales on the direct sales channel and charge higher wholesale prices in the reselling channel by improving product quality. Third, in the face of the channel competition, the retailer can adopt the following information acquisition strategies: when manufacturer’s direct sales efficiency is high, the retailer commits to acquire information to encourage manufacturers to improve product quality. When the direct selling efficiency is moderate, contingent acquisition is always a weakly dominant strategy. When the direct selling efficiency is low, the competition effect of direct selling channels is small, the retailer will make his information acquisition decision depending on the fixed cost of information acquisition. Specifically, when the cost of information acquisition is low, the retailer will adopt contingent acquisition to induce manufacturers to improve product quality. When the cost of information acquisition is relatively high and the direct sales efficiency is very low, realizing that the manufacturer has no motivation to improve quality, the retailer will adopt committed acquisition to encourage the manufacturer to enhance quality.Our study is also subject to some limitations and various related directions can be explored in future research. First, our analysis is constructed on the assumption that consumers can accurately perceive product quality. In fact, if the manufacturer does not disclose any information about a newly developed product, the product properties will be usually difficult to be observed before the use phase. Hence, the manufacturer’s quality disclosure strategy is worthy of further study. Second, it is worth mentioning that all the analyses in this paper are under the dual-channel configuration, and the manufacturer’s encroachment decision, i.e., whether to build up a direct channel or not, can be a good candidate for future exploration. In addition, although the upstream firms’ incentive for encroachment has been widely studied, it is still interesting to investigate the retailer’s optimal information strategy under the potential encroachment. Last but not least, we bypass the unit production cost to capture the industries where the quality investment cost is high but the production cost is extremely low. However, in some other industries（such as auto industry） production costs cannot be ignored. Therefore, future research can discuss the manufacturer’s quality investment strategy in consideration of production costs and the retailer’s information strategy.