Supplier Encroachment, Information Sharing, and Channel Structure in Online Retail Platforms

Albert Y. Ha,Huajiang Luo,Weixin Shang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/poms.13607
IF: 4.638
2021-11-26
Production and Operations Management
Abstract:In this study, we develop a game‐theoretic model to study the encroachment and information sharing decisions in a supply chain with a manufacturer selling through an online retail platform. In the base model, the manufacturer decides whether to encroach or not by selling through an agency channel, in addition to an existing reselling channel, at the same platform, who decides whether or not to share information with the manufacturer. We fully characterize the equilibrium decisions and show how they depend on the commission rate of the agency channel, channel substitutability, and information accuracy. Our analysis unfolds a novel wholesale price effect that extends related results in the literature. We also show that encroachment and information sharing are complementary, and therefore managers should not ignore the impact of one decision on the other decision even when the latter is not a primary motivation of the former. We study several model extensions to obtain additional insights and show that the major findings of the base model are robust and remain mostly valid when some modeling assumptions are changed.
operations research & management science,engineering, manufacturing
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to address the interaction between supplier encroachment (i.e., manufacturers selling products directly through agency channels) and information sharing decisions on online retail platforms. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following three main research questions: 1. **What motivates online retail platforms to share demand information with manufacturers?** - The paper explores whether platforms have the incentive to share demand information with manufacturers under different conditions. For example, when the platform charges a commission on the manufacturer's sales, it may be more inclined to share information to increase sales volume. 2. **How does information sharing affect the manufacturer's encroachment decision?** - Whether the manufacturer will add an agency channel for sales in addition to the existing resale channel. The paper analyzes how information sharing influences this decision and how this decision, in turn, affects the motivation for information sharing. 3. **How do these decisions depend on factors such as the commission rate of the agency channel, channel substitutability, and information accuracy?** - The paper studies in detail how these factors influence the manufacturer's encroachment decision and the platform's information sharing decision. For example, when the commission rate is low and information accuracy is high, the manufacturer is more likely to choose encroachment. By establishing a multi-stage game model, the paper reveals the complementary relationship between information sharing and channel structure decisions and demonstrates how these decisions are influenced by various factors. The paper also further validates the robustness of the main findings by extending the model.