Abstract:Abstract Collective dynamics emerge from countless individual decisions. Yet, we poorly understand the processes governing dynamically-interacting individuals in human collectives under realistic conditions. We present a naturalistic immersive-reality experiment where groups of participants searched for rewards in different environments, studying how individuals weigh personal and social information and how this shapes individual and collective outcomes. Capturing high-resolution visual-spatial data, behavioral analyses revealed individual-level gains—but group-level losses—of high social information use and spatial proximity in environments with concentrated (vs. distributed) resources. Incentivizing participants at the group (vs. individual) level facilitated adaptation to concentrated environments, buffering apparently excessive scrounging. To infer discrete choices from unconstrained interactions and uncover the underlying decision mechanisms, we developed an unsupervised Social Hidden Markov Decision model. Computational results showed that participants were more sensitive to social information in concentrated environments frequently switching to a social relocation state where they approach successful group members. Group-level incentives reduced participants’ overall responsiveness to social information and promoted higher selectivity over time. Finally, mapping group-level spatio-temporal dynamics through time-lagged regressions revealed a collective exploration-exploitation trade-off across different timescales. Our study unravels the processes linking individual-level strategies to emerging collective dynamics, and provides tools to investigate decision-making in freely-interacting collectives.

Optimal incentives for collective intelligence

Incentivizing free riders improves collective intelligence in social dilemmas

Does Spending More Always Ensure Higher Cooperation? An Analysis of Institutional Incentives on Heterogeneous Networks

From prediction markets to interpretable collective intelligence

Collective incentives reduce over-exploitation of social information in unconstrained human groups

Agents seeking long-term access to the wisdom of the crowd reduce immediate decision-making accuracy

Using Prediction Markets to Incentivize and Measure Collective Knowledge Production

Network dynamics of social influence in the wisdom of crowds

How social influence can undermine the wisdom of crowd effect

The impact of diversity on group decision-making in the face of the free-rider problem

Human collective intelligence as distributed Bayesian inference

The functional aspects of selective exposure for collective decision-making under social influence

Intergroup Competition Mitigates Effects of Reward Structure on Preference-Consistency Bias and Group Decision Failure

Cost efficiency of institutional incentives for promoting cooperation in finite populations

Correlated Information Reduces Accuracy of Pioneering Decision-Makers

Information Signal Design for Incentivizing Team Formation

Information Synergy Maximizes the Growth Rate of Heterogeneous Groups

Incentivizing honest performative predictions with proper scoring rules

Collective decision-making under changing social environments among agents adapted to sparse connectivity

Optimization of institutional incentives for cooperation in structured populations