Abstract:Introduction Community engagement and participatory research are widely used and considered important for ethical health research and interventions. Based on calls to unpack their complexity and observed biases in their favour, we conducted a realist review with a focus on non-communicable disease prevention. The aim was to generate an understanding of how and why engagement or participatory practices enhance or hinder the benefits of non-communicable disease research and interventions in low- and middle-income countries. Methods We retroductively formulated theories based on existing literature and realist interviews. After initial searches, preliminary theories and a search strategy were developed. We searched three databases and screened records with a focus on theoretical and empirical relevance. Insights about contexts, strategies, mechanisms and outcomes were extracted and synthesised into six theories. Five realist interviews were conducted to complement literature-based theorising. The final synthesis included 17 quality-appraised articles describing 15 studies. Results We developed six theories explaining how community engagement or participatory research practices either enhance or hinder the benefits of non-communicable disease research or interventions. Benefit-enhancing mechanisms include community members’ agency being realised, a shared understanding of the benefits of health promotion, communities feeling empowered, and community members feeling solidarity and unity. Benefit-hindering mechanisms include community members’ agency remaining unrealised and participation being driven by financial motives or reputational expectations. Conclusion Our review challenges assumptions about community engagement and participatory research being solely beneficial in the context of non-communicable disease prevention in low- and middle-income countries. We present both helpful and harmful pathways through which health and research outcomes are affected. Our practical recommendations relate to maximising benefits and minimising harm by addressing institutional inflexibility and researcher capabilities, managing expectations on research, promoting solidarity in solving public health challenges and sharing decision-making power.

Perspectives of community members on community-based participatory research: A systematic literature review

A realist evaluation of community-based participatory research: partnership synergy, trust building and related ripple effects

Impact of Participatory Health Research: A Test of the Community-Based Participatory Research Conceptual Model

Structural Community Governance: Importance for Community‐Academic Research Partnerships

Interrogation, Negotiation, and Subversion of Power Differentials in Community-Based Participatory Research: A Scoping Review

Community-Based Participatory Research (CBPR) to Enhance Participation of Racial/Ethnic Minorities in Clinical Trials: A 10-Year Systematic Review

Neighbors' Perceptions of University Engaged "Research"

Academic-Community Partnerships: Effectiveness Evaluated Beyond the Ivory Walls

Engaging people with lived experiences on community advisory boards in community-based participatory research: a scoping review protocol

Community-engaged pedagogy: a strengths-based approach to involving diverse stakeholders in research partnerships

Sharing of grant funds between academic institutions and community partners in community-based participatory research

Use of community engagement strategies to increase research participation in practice-based research networks (PBRNs)

Leveraging a Community-Based Research Approach to Explore Research Perceptions among Suburban Poor and Underserved Populations

Taking responsibility: Institutional agents of color (Re)imagine collaboration that centers community stakeholders in university-community partnerships

Addressing the challenges of Latino health research: participatory approaches in an emergent urban community

Engaging African American women in research: an approach to eliminate health disparities in the African American community

Enhanced or hindered research benefits? A realist review of community engagement and participatory research practices for non-communicable disease prevention in low- and middle-income countries

A funding initiative for community-based participatory research: lessons from the Harvard Catalyst Seed Grants

Negotiating access to community-based participatory research

Looking for impact in all the wrong places: Setting realistic expectations and measurable outcomes for small-scale community building initiatives

Power, Privilege, and Precarity: Attempts to Conduct Ethical Youth Participatory Action Research as Early Career Researchers