Reply to Soldo, A.; Lipej, L. Comment on "Balàka et al. Updated Checklist of Chondrichthyan Species in Croatia (Central Mediterranean Sea). Biology 2023, 12, 952"

Pia F. Balàka,Pero Ugarković,Julia Türtscher,Jürgen Kriwet,Simone Niedermüller,Patrik Krstinić,Patrick L. Jambura

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/biology13030136

2024-02-22

Biology

Abstract:Biology, Vol. 13, Pages 136: Reply to Soldo, A.; Lipej, L. Comment on “Balàka et al. Updated Checklist of Chondrichthyan Species in Croatia (Central Mediterranean Sea). Biology 2023, 12, 952” Biology doi: 10.3390/biology13030136 Authors: Pia F. Balàka Pero Ugarković Julia Türtscher Jürgen Kriwet Simone Niedermüller Patrik Krstinić Patrick L. Jambura Balàka et al [...]

biology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main issue that this paper attempts to address is the necessity and accuracy of the species list of cartilaginous fish in Croatia (Central Mediterranean). Specifically:

1. **Necessity of the National List**:
- The authors of the paper argue that despite the existence of species lists covering the Adriatic Sea, it is still necessary to compile a national list for Croatia. This is because a national list helps support national biodiversity management and facilitates the translation of regional and global legislation into national legislation, policies, and management measures.
- A national list is crucial for establishing a robust national species monitoring system and tracking changes in biodiversity.

2. **Accuracy of Species Identification**:
- The authors question the records of certain species, particularly the record of Carcharias taurus (sand tiger shark). They believe that previous records might be misidentifications and that the actual species could be the similar-looking Odontaspis ferox (smalltooth sand tiger).
- The authors support this view through detailed morphological feature analysis, including color patterns, dorsal fin position, and eye size.

3. **Discussion of Specific Species**:
- For Scyliorhinus duhamelii (Duhamel's catshark), the authors discuss its presence and validity in the Mediterranean, although it remains controversial.
- For Squatina aculeata (sawback angelshark), the authors provide sufficient scientific evidence to prove its presence in Croatia.

4. **Other Issues**:
- The paper also responds to Soldo and Lipej's criticisms on specific issues, such as the unconfirmed record of Sphyrna tudes (smalleye hammerhead) and the omission of some references.

Overall, the paper aims to emphasize the importance and accuracy of compiling a species list of cartilaginous fish in Croatia through detailed scientific analysis and discussion, and to respond to criticisms and doubts from other researchers.