Abstract:Scholars and politicians often complain about how weak administrative law enforcement is in China. To better understand the challenges in law enforcement, as well as variation in actual practices and influences on such practices, the current paper analyzes Chinese pollution law enforcement data from the last two decades as well as in depth qualitative case studies of everyday enforcement practices. It finds that recently enforcement has become much more frequent and stricter. It finds that recent changes in national legislation, centralization reforms, increased citizen complaints, as well as enforcement campaigns all played a role in this. While this has helped strengthen enforcement, and maybe has played a part in recent pollution reductions, it has not fundamentally overcome structural enforcement impediments. The increased authority, independence, and pressure on environmental authorities for stricter enforcement, does not seem to be matched with sufficient investment in resource capacity and support for regular procedural enforcement practices. In addition, the ad-hoc pressure on enforcement has undermined regular legal procedure and stimulated greater socio-economic inequality. These findings about pollution enforcement force us to question simplistic static generalizations of administrative law enforcement and instead develop both large-scale studies that map change over time as well as in-depth case studies that provide a thorough picture of actual practices on the ground. Moreover, the paper concludes that a true picture of administrative enforcement must move beyond looking at the enforcement itself, to looking at how it arrives at the regulated companies and shapes their compliance.

Research on the Reform Path of Comprehensive Administrative Law Enforcement System in Kunming

Transforming the Evaluation of the Rule of Law in China

Strengthen the Execution of Rural Law Administration and Realize Administration by Law

Assessment of the Rule of Law and Its Application in China

A Review of Administrative Law Research:2005-2006

Punishing Polluters: Trends, Local Practice, and Influences, and Their Implications for Administrative Law Enforcement in China

Retrospection of the Development of China'Administrative Rule of Law--Experience and Lesson

Research on the Optimization of Administrative Regulations Supervision and Operation—from the Perspective of Supervision and Supervision Cooperation

Research on the Modes of Policing Reform of China in Recent Ten Years——On the Change and Reconstruction of Investigative Subject

Principles and control planning of Three-old Lands Reform of Guangdong Province

A Re-Examination of the Function and Role of Administrative Lawsuit

On the Plight of Campaign-Styled Administrative Enforcement of Law and China's Governance

The Implementation and Reformation of Administrative Litigation Law in China

On Investigative Measures of Public Security Organs when Involved in a Public Security Case

Development and Construction of Special Administrative Law——A Perspective from Analysis on Police Law

Reform of Non-administrative Licensing Approval：Reviewing and Responding

Research on Legal Basis of Administrative Law Enforcement of Urban Management

Study on the reform dilemma and reform path of administrative examination and approval bureau

Structural restraints and institutional innovation in local governance: a case study of administrative examination and approval system reforms in Shunde, Ningbo, and Taizhou

On the Approaches of Strengthening the Subject of Agricultural Administrative Law Enforcement:A Case Study of a City in Heilongjiang Province

Breakthrough and Prospect of China's Administrative Substantive Law