Abstract:Some aspects of cognition are more taxing than others. Accordingly, many people will avoid cognitively demanding tasks in favor of simpler alternatives. Which components of these tasks are costly, and how much, remains unknown. Here, we use a novel task design in which subjects request wages for completing cognitive tasks and a computational modeling procedure that decomposes their wages into the costs driving them. Using working memory as a test case, our approach revealed that gating new information into memory and protecting against interference are costly. Critically, other factors, like memory load, appeared less costly. Other key factors which may drive effort costs, such as error avoidance, had minimal influence on wage requests. Our approach is sensitive to individual differences, and could be used in psychiatric populations to understand the true underlying nature of apparent cognitive deficits. Anyone who has tried to mentally calculate how much to tip at a restaurant knows that cognitive effort can feel aversive. Doing math in your head, like most high-level cognitive abilities, depends critically on working memory (WM). We know that WM is sometimes effortful to use, but we don't know which aspects of WM use drive these effort costs. To address this question, we had participants request wages in exchange for performing various tasks that differed in their specific WM demands. Using computational models of their wage demands, we demonstrated that some aspects of WM are costly, such as bringing new information into memory and preventing interference. Other factors, like the amount of information in memory and attempts to avoid mistakes, were less costly. Our approach identified which specific subcomponents of WM are aversive. Future research could use these methods to test theories about how motivational problems might be masquerading as cognitive deficits in psychiatric populations.

Shielding working memory from distraction is more effortful than flexible updating

Dual-task Costs in Memory Recall Precision Reflect Shared Representational Space

Need for cognition moderates cognitive effort aversion

Wagers for work: Decomposing the costs of cognitive effort

Neural systems of cognitive demand avoidance

Need for cognition moderates the relief of avoiding cognitive effort

Filtering distractors is costly

More Attention with Less Working Memory: the Active Inhibition of Attended but Outdated Information

Working Memory Capacity Predicts Focus Back Effort under Different Task Demands

Short-term memory capacity predicts willingness to expend cognitive effort for reward

Working memory components modulation of attentional disengagement from evaluative distractor

Flexible processing of distractor stimuli under stress

The Cognitive Cost of Repetitive Thinking: A Study on the Effects of Shifting and Updating on Rumination of Emotional Experiences

The controllosphere: The neural origin of cognitive effort.

Attentional switching between perception and memory: Examining asymmetrical switch costs

Attentional control and metacognitive monitoring of the effects of different types of task-irrelevant sound on serial recall.

Cognitive task avoidance correlates with fatigue-induced performance decrement but not with subjective fatigue

The role of cognitive effort in subjective reward devaluation and risky decision-making

Cognitive trait anxiety, situational stress, and mental effort predict shifting efficiency: Implications for attentional control theory.

Inhibition in selective attention

Trying Harder: How Cognitive Effort Sculpts Neural Representations during Working Memory