The CO2-in-water foam stabilized with the mixture of CO2-soluble surfactant and nonionic surfactant

Xuan Zhang,Tianci Zhang,Jijiang Ge,Yang Wang,Lei Ding,Guicai Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.petrol.2020.108117

IF: 5.168

2021-03-01

Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering

Abstract:In recent years, many studies focused on the foam behavior with CO2-soluble surfactants. However, it would be better if the mixing surfactants solution could increase the foam viscosities further and keep the considerable solubility in CO2 comparing with single CO2-soluble surfactant. In this paper, the synergism of the mixture of CO2-soluble surfactant composed of 2 ethoxylated amine headgroups with cocoalkyl tails (C12NEO2) and nonionic surfactant with high degree ethoxylation (C13EO12) was investigated quantitatively by interfacial tension measurement, including micelles in water phase and monolayer at CO2-water interface. Lower critical micelle concentration (CMC) and negative interaction parameters β σ represented the positive synergism clearly after adding nonionic surfactant to the switchable CO2-soluble surfactant. Importantly, the solubility in CO2 and the foam viscosity in porous media were analyzed comparably to confirm the engineering applicability. Even though the C13EO12 is hard to dissolve in CO2 solely, 0.2 wt% surfactants mixture (C13EO12 proportion was lower than 30%) could dissolve in CO2 absolutely to form transparent single-phase at 60 °C and 16 MPa. Limited to the mixture solubility in CO2, which means that the α(C13EO12) <0.3, the optimum surfactants ratio to get the best foam was C12NEO2:C13EO12 = 8:2, where the bulk foam stability and viscosity increased 1.5 and 2.5 times separately. It was attributed to that the positive synergism leaded to more compact surfactants adsorption layers at the interface, then more stable foam. With increasing brine salinity, the enhancement of foam viscosity diminished to a great extent, while the counter ions in brine could help to get more viscous foam stabilized with C12NEO2 alone.

energy & fuels,engineering, petroleum

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: how to improve the stability and viscosity of CO2 foam by mixing CO2 - soluble surfactant (C12NEO2) with non - ionic surfactant (C13EO12), while maintaining its solubility in CO2. Specifically, the researchers hope that this mixture can further increase the viscosity of the foam, and achieve better engineering application performance compared with a single CO2 - soluble surfactant while maintaining high CO2 solubility. The main research contents of the paper include: - **Surface tension measurement**: The synergistic effect between the two surfactants was quantitatively analyzed by measuring the critical micelle concentration (CMC) and interfacial tension of mixtures with different ratios. - **Solubility in CO2**: The solubility of the mixture in supercritical CO2 was studied. In particular, when the proportion of C13EO12 is less than 30%, the mixture can be completely dissolved in CO2 at 60 °C and 16 MPa to form a transparent single phase. - **Foam behavior**: The foam stability and apparent viscosity of the mixture in porous media were evaluated. It was found that when the optimal ratio of C12NEO2:C13EO12 = 8:2, the foam stability and viscosity were increased by 1.5 times and 2.5 times respectively. These research results are of great significance for improving the CO2 flooding efficiency, especially in reducing the mobility of CO2 in porous media. By forming stable foams, the oil recovery rate can be effectively increased.

The CO2-in-water foam stabilized with the mixture of CO2-soluble surfactant and nonionic surfactant

Interfacial properties and foam performance of alpha olefin sulfonate and CO2 switchable aminopropyl methyl siloxane surfactant mixtures

CO2 in water foam stabilized with CO2-dissolved surfactant at high pressure and high temperature

CO2/N2 switchable aqueous foam stabilized by SDS/C12A surfactants: Experimental and molecular simulation studies

Temperature and salt resistant CO2 responsive gas well foam: Experimental and molecular simulation study

A Comparative Study on CO2-Switchable Foams Stabilized by C22- or C18-Tailed Tertiary Amines

Synergistic improvement of foam stability with SiO2 nanoparticles (SiO2-NPs) and different surfactants

Switchability and synergistic effect of a CO 2 -responsive surfactant with co-surfactants at an O/W interface: A molecular insight

A Novel Supercritical CO2 Foam System Stabilized With a Mixture of Zwitterionic Surfactant and Silica Nanoparticles for Enhanced Oil Recovery

CO2-Soluble Ionic Surfactants and CO2 Foams for High-Temperature and High-Salinity Sandstone Reservoirs

Evaluation of the interfacial elasticity of surfactant monolayer at the CO 2 –water interface by molecular dynamics simulation: Screening surfactants to enhance the CO 2 foam stability

Molecular dynamics simulation of the synergistic effect of a compound surfactant on the stability of CO2 oil‐based foam

Ethanol enhanced anionic surfactant solubility in CO2 and CO2 foam stability: MD simulation and experimental investigations

Static and dynamic foam/oil interactions: Potential of CO2-philic surfactants as mobility control agents

Foaming in aqueous solutions of mixtures of a zwitterionic and a cationic surfactant in presence of an electrolyte

An Experiment and Molecular Dynamics Simulation of Synergistic Foaming between a Surfactant and CO2 and the Structure–Activity Effect

Effect of the number of hydroxyl groups of CO2-triggered surfactants on capability and performance in CO2-stimulated response

Design of nanoparticles for generation and stabilization of CO2-in-brine foams with or without added surfactants

Surfactant in a Polyol–CO 2 Mixture: Insights from a Classical Density Functional Theory Study

Preparation of styrene‐phenylamine monomer copolymer nanospheres and its performance for stabilizing CO2 foam