Big Data on Important Issues: Assessing the Needs of Student and Early Career Aquatic Scientists
Susanne Menden‐Deuer,Laura Bristow,Hideyuki Doi,Christopher Filstrup,Andrea Johnson,Kevin Rose,Xiao Xi,Amy Burgess,Grace Wilkinson
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/lob.10052
2015-01-01
Limnology and Oceanography Bulletin
Abstract:ASLO is very fortunate in that we have a high (>30%) contingent of “young” (by career stage) members, which is part of the reason ASLO has such tremendous fidelity. One of ASLO's core missions is to foster the professional development of our members at a range of career stages and this goal permeates the new strategic plan, with key strategic goals including professionalization and vitality. The ASLO board has been very supportive of both student and EC members and funds travel awards and workshops, amongst other opportunities. Student and Early Career members are outstanding participants at ASLO meetings, contribute to reviewing for the journal, and serve as meeting mentors. The ASLO Early Career Committee (ECC) is charged with the creation and organization of programs and the development of initiatives targeted to benefit ASLO's early-career members. The interpretation of “early career” status is roughly for members from time of completion of the Ph.D. to 10 years thereafter. The “definition” is not set in stone, to allow for variations in career event timing, reflecting the diversity of career paths our members take, including transitions and non-professional events. The ECC provides support for ASLO early career members, including services in relation to ASLO meetings (e.g., travel awards, networking, mixers, and workshops) as well as providing information on career related opportunities (e.g., job postings, resources, opportunities) mainly communicated through the ASLO website. For example, for the February 2015 Aquatic Sciences meeting in Granada, Spain, the ECC, lead by Laura Bristow (Univ. of Southern Denmark) organized a workshop that provided an overview of the Marie Skłodowska-Curie fellowship programs funded by the European Union. These fellowships are available to individuals wanting to pursue post-doctoral research in Europe and internationally. Beyond an overview, a panel of reviewers, applicants and recipients of the program, the workshop provided access to the Spanish representative of the program (Cristina Gómez Corchete). The workshop was well attended and feedback indicated a huge demand for events of this type. Similar events are organized for ASLO student members (see Wilkinson's article on benefits of student membership in this issue). The evening mixers, held adjacently for students and EC members was much more informal, very well attended and a great opportunity to meet colleagues old and new—drink tickets ran out much before crowds dissipated. To ensure ASLO is serving its EC and student members appropriately and we don't miss any opportunities to meet the needs of our EC and student members, together the ECC and ASLO student board members developed a survey specific for that demographic. In spring of 2015, the survey was sent out to the just shy of 2300 EC and student members. The default was anonymous and voluntary (of course!) participation. Below we list the questions asked, summaries of the responses (quantitative data only) and the actionable items we developed. The latter were inspired by the very thoughtful comments provided by respondents, which unfortunately cannot be reproduced here (the nearly 519 pages were not accepted for inclusion in the Bulletin). Naturally, this survey was not created or analyzed “scientifically” and we only used it to provide information on broad trends. We would welcome any and all comments you might have. Hopefully, this survey will provide insights into how ASLO is and will continue to promote its “younger” members. The survey certainly has been very useful for those of us in charge of creating, developing and organizing programs and events targeted to benefit student and EC members. The survey was emailed to 2293 recipients, all of whom were 2014–2015 EC and student members and of those recipients 430 responded (18% response rate). The response was evenly split between students (218) and EC members (211). The duration of ASLO membership of respondents was well spread, including ~40% (178) first year members, ~20% (81) 2nd year, and ~40% (169) 3+ year members. The current travel award provided for students varies depending on location and ranges from $250 to $750. Early Career travel awards have been fixed at $500 for the last few meetings. We were interested if members felt travel award amounts should be tailored depending on meeting location (recognizing that total funds are not unlimited). Seventy percent (280) of respondents preferred a travel award sum of $500, but both $250 awards (48) and $1000 (65) were thought desirable. A number of comments suggested travel awards of $750. Another item we wanted clarification on, was whether EC and student members thought it was desirable to request travel award applicants or recipients to “give back” to ASLO in some way through volunteering, by enhancing the probability of award success for those who had served the society (by, e.g., reviewing or mentoring). Approximately 75% of respondents (325) thought it was fair and desirable to enhance the probability of an award to those who had contributed to ASLO vs. 98 respondents who did not think it was desirable to do so. Very encouragingly, most respondents stated that they would do anything possible to attend an ASLO meeting, if they could find the necessary funds. Respondents were concerned about carbon footprint issues associated with meeting travel; another common concern stated was how to provide child care. This input mirrors discussions the ASLO Board has been having, reflecting the same concerns. Clearly, ASLO meetings are attractive to EC and student members and a strength the ASLO student board members and ECC will work hard to continue to retain. One of the strengths of ASLO is its commitment to effect change based on members input. As such, the responses summarized above have led to a number of changes, or modifications of current practices of the student and EC committees. Below some highlights: For the 2016 meetings and onwards, travel award allocations will take into account the distance traveled. Given the constraints of handling at times >500 applications, and minimizing the application effort, we will make the travel awards in 2 “flat rate” categories, depending on whether applicants are coming from on- or off- continent, relative to the meeting location ($500 and $750, respectively). While neither amount will cover the entire cost of the meeting, it should alleviate the burden of financing meeting attendance and for many, will provide leverage for other funding sources. Respondents' comments were very thoughtful and pointed to some possible, unintended consequences of proposed travel award changes. For example, it could be hard for students or new members to demonstrate they have contributed to ASLO. For first time applicants, we want the awards to be open to all new members and prior “volunteering” for ASLO will have no bearing on the probability of success. However, if someone has been a member several years and applied several times, they can enhance their award chances by volunteering for ASLO (see below). Lucky for ASLO, many respondents were keenly interested in opportunities to be involved with ASLO. Also luckily, ASLO has many opportunities for volunteer involvement, including committees that need dedicated members, meetings that are enhanced by presentation judges and mentors, and the need for reviewers at all of the ASLO journals. Of course there are also opportunities to review manuscripts and proposals in the broader scientific community. See http://aslo.org/committees/index.html and http://aslo.org/forms/volunteerform.php for ways to volunteer with ASLO. Particularly for the student and EC members, balancing the needs of attending professional meetings and balancing demands of the home life, (including but not limited to child care) is a very demanding task. ASLO does not currently offer childcare at meetings (it has been offered in the past but there were very few users of the service). While there are no “official” rules, children are typically welcome at ASLO meetings. Many parents bring their children to the poster session and there are rooms available for nursing and rooms where caretakers can take their children. ASLO also tries to provide names of local childcare services for parents to contact directly. We will work to make sure that the appropriate information is provided alongside meeting information. Recognizing that travel sometimes is just not possible, or desirable (see carbon footprint issue mentioned above), we are striving to make meetings more available to those who can't travel. While the face-to-face time at meetings might not be replaceable in the short term, there are plenary and award talks from ASLO meetings available online and provided in a user-friendly interface (i.e., YouTube). There is live tweeting at the conference and more is sure to come in the future. In the survey responses, there were diverse requests for funding from ASLO, including requests for international grants, individual research projects/tuition, bridge funding for recent Ph.Ds, to travel grants specific to developing nations. While allocation of funds for individual salaries or research projects is beyond ASLO's scope, there is a strong commitment to providing members with support, including funding, to enhance member's ability to do science and promote their careers. ASLO provides considerable support for these endeavors (e.g., travel awards, reduced registration for student/EC members, waived registration fees for developing nations members). Moreover, ASLO provides training opportunities to enhance the competitiveness of its members in obtaining funding. These are just some of the changes taking effect and we look forward to continued feedback on how we can enhance ASLO services to student and EC members. These improvements would not be possible without the tremendous engagement of student and EC members in ASLO. Thus, most importantly, we thank all of the respondents very much for filling out the online survey. The response was fantastic, both in terms of participation and the level of information provided and gave us much needed guidance for our future efforts, which to a large extent will continue the services ASLO has been offering and now we know with renewed assurance that career building and networking opportunities remain in great demand. Please do not hesitate to contact us with ideas, concerns or compliments. Your guidance of our efforts on behalf of the student and EC ASLO members is essential (and hopefully effective). The student board members and early career committee organize professional development workshops at ASLO conferences. Shown here, Brian Palermo leading “Snap It Up,” a workshop in Granada focused on improving scientific presentations. Photo by Adrienne Sponberg. The mixers for students and early career members at ASLO conferences are always well-attended. Photo by Adrienne Sponberg. We would like to thank Adrienne Sponberg for valuable feedback on this article as well as contributing the photos of early career/student workshops and events.