Focused for Some, Exploratory for Others: Job Search Strategies and Successful University-to-Work Transitions in the Context of Labor Market Ambiguity

Belgin Okay-Somerville,Dora Scholarios
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/08948453211016058
2021-05-18
Journal of Career Development
Abstract:This article examines the role of student job search strategies that differ in goal-directedness (focused, exploratory, and haphazard) in achieving successful university-to-work transitions (i.e., employment in jobs with high skill use/development and qualification–job match). The relationship between job search and employment outcomes is considered in two labor market contexts—high or low ambiguity—which are represented by the comparison between arts, humanities, and social sciences (AHSS) and science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) graduates, respectively. Using two-wave survey data, we find that job search strategies during university do not explain, yet differentially impact, successful outcomes one year after graduation. Fully exploring opportunities was particularly beneficial for STEM graduates (low ambiguity context) and more focused job search was beneficial for AHSS graduates (high ambiguity context). Paradoxically, findings both question and reinforce the efficacy of career agency for overcoming barriers to labor market entry, depending on the job search context. The study contributes to the agency and context debates relevant for school-to-work transitions.
psychology, applied
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how the job - seeking strategies of students with different goal - orientations affect their successful transition from college to work in the context of labor market uncertainty. Specifically, the author explores the impact of job - seeking strategies with different goal - orientations (focused, exploratory, and random) on the employment quality of graduates, especially the differences between graduates in Arts, Humanities and Social Sciences (AHSS) with higher employment opportunity uncertainty and those in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics (STEM) with lower uncertainty. The paper analyzes the performance of job - seeking strategies in the last semester of college and their impact on the employment results of students one year after graduation through two - wave survey data. The study finds that the exploratory job - seeking strategy is particularly beneficial to STEM graduates, while a more focused job - seeking strategy is more beneficial to AHSS graduates. These findings both question and reinforce the effectiveness of career autonomy in overcoming barriers to labor market entry, depending on the background conditions of job - seeking. The research contributions are as follows: 1. Combining individual agency and contextual factors to understand career transitions. 2. Going beyond the quantity of job - seeking and focusing on the quality of job - seeking, especially in terms of the goal - orientation of job - seeking strategies, which has incremental validity for predicting employment outcomes. In conclusion, this paper aims to reveal how job - seeking strategies affect the successful transition from college to work under different labor market uncertainty conditions by examining the job - seeking strategies of graduates with different disciplinary backgrounds.