Strengthening derivation chains in cognitive neuroscience: Closing Editorial

Daniel Mirman,Anne Scheel,Anna-Lena Schubert,Robert D. McIntosh
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cortex.2024.04.004
IF: 4.644
2024-04-28
Cortex
Abstract:This volume of Cortex sees the publication of the last three of the nine articles forming the special issue, Strengthening Derivation Chains in Cognitive Neuroscience (Mirman et al., 2022). Our goal in proposing this topic was to encourage and collect exemplars of rigorous work that lays and strengthens the foundations of research in cognitive neuroscience, from the conceptual entities studied, to the tools and measures to operationalise them and the pipelines through which we process the data. These are core elements of the "derivation chains" that connect abstract scientific claims to concrete observations and thus underpin higher-level hypothesis tests (Meehl, 1990; Scheel et al., 2021). The validity of any hypothesis test (and indeed any inference to abstract claims from data) depends upon the integrity of its derivation chain, and so we need to ensure that the constituent links are secure. The articles in this collection exemplify this kind of foundational research and illustrate its diversity. They also suggest to us some roads for improving cognitive neuroscience research, which we point towards in this brief editorial. The nine articles will be considered in relation to two main themes: methodological development and concept development.
behavioral sciences,psychology, experimental,neurosciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?