Abstract:Numerous studies suggest that biological neuronal networks self-organize toward a critical state with stable recruitment dynamics. Individual neurons would then statistically activate exactly one further neuron during activity cascades termed neuronal avalanches. Yet, it is unclear if and how this can be reconciled with the explosive recruitment dynamics within neocortical minicolumns in vivo and within neuronal clusters in vitro , which indicates that neurons form supercritical local circuits. Theoretical studies propose that modular networks with a mix of regionally subcritical and supercritical dynamics would create apparently critical dynamics, resolving this inconsistency. Here, we provide experimental support by manipulating the structural self-organization process of networks of cultured rat cortical neurons (either sex). Consistent with the prediction, we show that increasing clustering in neuronal networks developing in vitro strongly correlates with avalanche size distributions transitioning from supercritical to subcritical activity dynamics. Avalanche size distributions approximated a power law in moderately clustered networks, indicating overall critical recruitment. We propose that activity-dependent self-organization can tune inherently supercritical networks toward mesoscale criticality by creating a modular structure in neuronal networks. SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT Critical recruitment dynamics in neuronal networks are considered optimal for information processing in the brain. However, it remains heavily debated how neuronal networks would self-organize criticality by detailed fine-tuning of connectivity, inhibition, and excitability. We provide experimental support for theoretical considerations that modularity tunes critical recruitment dynamics at the mesoscale level of interacting neuron clusters. This reconciles reports of supercritical recruitment dynamics in local neuron clusters with findings on criticality sampled at mesoscopic network scales. Intriguingly, altered mesoscale organization is a prominent aspect of various neuropathological diseases currently investigated in the framework of criticality. We therefore believe that our findings would also be of interest for clinical scientists searching to link the functional and anatomic signatures of such brain disorders.

25 years of criticality in neuroscience -- established results, open controversies, novel concepts

Criticality, Connectivity, and Neural Disorder: A Multifaceted Approach to Neural Computation

Theoretical foundations of studying criticality in the brain

Is criticality a unified set-point of brain function?

Criticality meets learning: Criticality signatures in a self-organizing recurrent neural network

Criticality in the brain: A synthesis of neurobiology, models and cognition

Evaluation of the criticality of in vitro neuronal networks: Toward an assessment of computational capacity

A General Description of Criticality in Neural Network Models

A toy model for brain criticality: self-organized excitation/inhibition ratio and the role of network clustering

Controlling extended criticality via modular connectivity

Critical role for resource constraints in neural models

Criticality & Deep Learning I: Generally Weighted Nets

Structural Modularity Tunes Mesoscale Criticality in Biological Neuronal Networks

Criticality, stability, competition, and consolidation of new representations in brain networks

Critical neural networks with short and long term plasticity

Critical excitation-inhibition balance in dense neural networks

Homeostatic plasticity and emergence of functional networks in a whole-brain model at criticality

The Cognitive Critical Brain: Modulation of Criticality in Perception-Related Cortical Regions

Criticality explains structure-function relationships in the human brain

Internal Representations in Spiking Neural Networks, criticality and the Renormalization Group

Unveiling the intrinsic dynamics of biological and artificial neural networks: from criticality to optimal representations