Impact of the measurement conditions and compression paddle on mammography dosimeter response

Maysa Costa de Castro,Paula Toroi,Mika Kortesniemi,Carita Lindholm,Massimo Pinto,Luigi Rinaldi,Aino Tietäväinen,Joonas Tikkanen,Miloš Živanović
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejmp.2024.103405
IF: 3.119
2024-06-14
Physica Medica
Abstract:Highlights • Impact of the measurement conditions was evaluated on mammography dosimeters. • Measurement condition might have a significant > 5 % impact on the response of a semiconductor-based X-ray multimeter. • X-ray multimeter should be calibrated with the correct settings and representative beams. The effect of mammography measurement conditions was investigated to evaluate their impact on measurement uncertainties in clinical practice. The most prominent physical X-ray beam quantities i.e., − air kerma, half-value layer, and X-ray tube voltage − were examined by measuring the response of two ionization chambers and six X-ray multimeters (XMMs) of different models. Measurements were performed using several anode/filter combinations and both with and without the compression paddle in the X-ray beam. Maximum differences of higher than 6 % were found for all quantities when the dosimeter displayed value was compared with the reference value or the variation within the clinical anode/filter combinations Mo/Mo and Mo/Rh were considered. The study showed that the calibration procedure with the W/Al anode/filter combination was reliable only for ionization chambers, and the response of XMMs varies in such a way that the calibration coefficient cannot be predicted between various measurement conditions used in calibration and clinical practices. XMM calibrations are typically performed without a compression paddle in the beam, and the response of the XMM changes when radiation quality is slightly altered. If XMM specific data is not available, based on this study, an additional uncertainty of 2 % ( k = 1) could be used as a typical estimate, at least for air kerma measurements. XMMs should be used for clinical measurements in mammography only with correct settings. If the correct settings are not available, the XMMs should not be used or used only with extreme caution.
radiology, nuclear medicine & medical imaging
What problem does this paper attempt to address?