Review of Cell-Balancing Schemes for Electric Vehicle Battery Management Systems

Adnan Ashraf,Basit Ali,Mothanna S. A. Alsunjury,Hakime Goren,Halise Kilicoglu,Faysal Hardan,Pietro Tricoli

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/en17061271

IF: 3.2

2024-03-07

Energies

Abstract:The battery pack is at the heart of electric vehicles, and lithium-ion cells are preferred because of their high power density, long life, high energy density, and viability for usage in relatively high and low temperatures. Lithium-ion batteries are negatively affected by overvoltage, undervoltage, thermal runaway, and cell voltage imbalance. The minimisation of cell imbalance is particularly important because it causes uneven power dissipation by each cell and, hence, temperature distribution that adversely impacts the battery lifetime. Several papers in the literature proposed advanced cell-balancing techniques to increase the effectiveness of basic cell-balancing approaches, reduce power losses, and reduce the number of components in balancing circuits. The new developments and optimisations over the last few years have been particularly intense due to the increased interest in battery technologies for several end-use applications. This paper reviews and discusses recent cell-balancing techniques or methods, covering their operating principles and the optimised utilisation of electrical components.

energy & fuels

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the paper attempts to solve

This paper aims to solve the voltage imbalance problem among battery cells in the Battery Management Systems (BMS) of electric vehicles. Specifically, lithium - ion batteries are increasingly widely used in electric vehicles, but due to problems such as over - voltage, under - voltage, thermal runaway and battery cell voltage imbalance, the performance and lifespan of lithium - ion batteries have been seriously affected. Among them, the voltage or State of Charge (SOC) imbalance among battery cells is particularly crucial, because this will lead to uneven power dissipation in each battery cell, which in turn affects the overall temperature distribution of the battery and shortens the battery life.

To address these problems, many studies have proposed advanced battery cell balancing techniques to improve the effectiveness of basic battery cell balancing methods, reduce power losses, and reduce the number of components in the balancing circuit. This paper reviews the battery cell balancing techniques proposed in recent years and discusses the working principles of these techniques and their optimal utilization of electrical components.

### Main content

1. **Introduction**:
- Briefly describes the importance of the Battery Management Systems in electric vehicles.
- Emphasizes the negative impacts of battery cell imbalance on battery performance, safety and lifespan.
- Outlines the traditional passive and active battery cell balancing methods.

2. **Traditional battery cell balancing methods**:
- Introduces the basic principles of passive and active battery cell balancing.
- Discusses the advantages and disadvantages of each method.

3. **New - type battery cell balancing techniques**:
- **Closed - Loop Switched - Capacitor Structure (CLSCS)**:
- Proposes a battery cell balancing method based on the Closed - Loop Switched - Capacitor Structure, using PI control to achieve rapid voltage equalization.
- Improves the balancing efficiency by optimizing the switching frequency.
- **Resonant Switched - Capacitor Equalizer in Parallel (ReSCE)**:
- Utilizes LC circuits to limit the inrush current and achieve efficient energy transfer.
- Increases the balancing speed compared with the traditional Pure Switched - Capacitor (PSC) method.
- **Single - Inductor Bidirectional Battery Cell Balancing**:
- Proposes a single - inductor multi - channel battery cell balancing technique, achieving rapid balancing by adjusting the switch duty cycle.
- Provides multiple energy transfer modes, increasing flexibility.
- **Coupled - Inductor Battery Cell Balancing**:
- Achieves efficient energy transfer between battery cells through coupled inductors.
- Reduces the number of required inductors, reducing cost and magnetic loss.

4. **Conclusion**:
- Summarizes the characteristics, advantages and disadvantages of various battery cell balancing techniques.
- Points out the directions and challenges for future research.

### Formula examples

- **Closed - Loop Switched - Capacitor Structure (CLSCS)**:
- The balancing current \( I_{\text{bal}} \) can be expressed as:
\[
I_{\text{bal}}=\frac{V_{\text{diff}}}{R_{\text{eq}}}
\]
- Where \( V_{\text{diff}} \) is the voltage difference between battery cells, and \( R_{\text{eq}} \) is the equivalent resistance.

- **Resonant Switched - Capacitor Equalizer in Parallel (ReSCE)**:
- The resonant frequency \( f_{\text{res}} \) can be expressed as:
\[
f_{\text{res}}=\frac{1}{2\pi\sqrt{L_{\text{eq}}C_{\text{eq}}}}
\]
- Where \( L_{\text{eq}} \) and \( C_{\text{eq}} \) are the equivalent inductance and capacitance respectively.

- **Single - Inductor Bidirectional Battery Cell Balancing**:
- The balancing time \( T_{\text{bal}} \) can be expressed as:
\[
T_{\text{bal}}=\frac{Q_{\text{to}}