Abstract:In metagenomic studies of microbial communities, the short reads come from mixtures of genomes. Read assembly is usually an essential first step for the follow-up studies in metagenomic research. Understanding the power and limitations of various read assembly programs in practice is important for researchers to choose which programs to use in their investigations. Many studies evaluating different assembly programs used either simulated metagenomes or real metagenomes with unknown genome compositions. However, the simulated datasets may not reflect the real complexities of metagenomic samples and the estimated assembly accuracy could be misleading due to the unknown genomes in real metagenomes. Therefore, hybrid strategies are required to evaluate the various read assemblers for metagenomic studies. In this paper, we benchmark the metagenomic read assemblers by mixing reads from real metagenomic datasets with reads from known genomes and evaluating the integrity, contiguity and accuracy of the assembly using the reads from the known genomes. We selected four advanced metagenome assemblers, MEGAHIT, MetaSPAdes, IDBA-UD and Faucet, for evaluation. We showed the strengths and weaknesses of these assemblers in terms of integrity, contiguity and accuracy for different variables, including the genetic difference of the real genomes with the genome sequences in the real metagenomic datasets and the sequencing depth of the simulated datasets. Overall, MetaSPAdes performs best in terms of integrity and continuity at the species-level, followed by MEGAHIT. Faucet performs best in terms of accuracy at the cost of worst integrity and continuity, especially at low sequencing depth. MEGAHIT has the highest genome fractions at the strain-level and MetaSPAdes has the overall best performance at the strain-level. MEGAHIT is the most efficient in our experiments. Availability: The source code is available at https://github.com/ziyewang/MetaAssemblyEval.

MetaCONNET: A Metagenomic Polishing Tool for Long-Read Assemblies

NextPolish: a fast and efficient genome polishing tool for long-read assembly

The genome polishing tool POLCA makes fast and accurate corrections in genome assemblies

NextPolish2: A Repeat-aware Polishing Tool for Genomes Assembled Using HiFi Long Reads

Integrated De Novo Gene Prediction and Peptide Assembly of Metagenomic Sequencing Data

Scalable long read self-correction and assembly polishing with multiple sequence alignment

Highly accurate assembly polishing with DeepPolisher

Metamic: Reference-Free Misassembly Identification and Correction of De Novo Metagenomic Assemblies

GoldPolish-Target: Targeted long-read genome assembly polishing

Constructing telomere-to-telomere diploid genome by polishing haploid nanopore-based assembly

NextDenovo: an efficient error correction and accurate assembly tool for noisy long reads

Comparative evaluation of Nanopore polishing tools for microbial genome assembly and polishing strategies for downstream analysis

Assessment of Metagenomic Assemblers Based on Hybrid Reads of Real and Simulated Metagenomic Sequences

Benchmarking short and long read polishing tools for nanopore assemblies: achieving near-perfect genomes for outbreak isolates

Benchmarking of Long-Read Sequencing, Assemblers and Polishers for Yeast Genome

Homopolish: a method for the removal of systematic errors in nanopore sequencing by homologous polishing

Benchmarking of bioinformatics tools for the hybrid de novo assembly of human whole-genome sequencing data

Pre-Assembly NGS Correction of ONT Reads Achieves HiFi-Level Assembly Quality

Fast and Accurate Assembly of Nanopore Reads Via Progressive Error Correction and Adaptive Read Selection

MiniScrub: de novo long read scrubbing using approximate alignment and deep learning

AsmMix: an efficient haplotype-resolved hybrid de novo genome assembling pipeline