Training physicians to be administrators.

P. Manga,C. Lay
1992-07-01
Abstract:Tn he article "Can physicians afford not to get involved in hospital administration?" (Can Med Assoc J 1992; 146: 751-754), by Dr. Peter P. Morgan and Lynne Cohen, makes many references to the master's in health administration (MHA) program at the University of Ottawa. Yet not a single current full-time professor in the, program was quoted or interviewed for the article. I strongly resent the unexamined and gratuitous denigration of the MHA program by people who are basically nonentities or passe in our field. Most of the physicians who have gone through our program would concur with the view of Dr. Catherine McCourt (one of our alumni) that the program "offered her everything she wanted, and exposed her to the expertise and points of view of other medical and nonmedical professionals." Our MHA program is currently being taken by two physicians and a dentist. Managerial and administrative positions in health care should be filled by people with the requisite knowledge, experience, skills and competence. In general, such people do not need to be physicians. However, in any job calling for the direct management of a clinical function the person with both the clinical background and the managerial training would have a decisive edge over someone without clinical training. For such specialized and focused positions, the training program run by the Physician Manager Institute may be preferable and is certainly cheaper than a 2-year MHA program. In general, managerial or administrative positions in health care should not be reserved exclusively for physicians, since a broad range of nonclinical skills and experience is required for effective performance. Physicians who have broadened their base are eagerly sought, but there is no single best way to train them for such positions. Morgan and Cohen fail to
What problem does this paper attempt to address?