Comparative Study of the Accuracies and Efficiencies of Dual-layer Spectral CT, QCT, and DXA for Osteoporosis Diagnosis

WANG Mengmeng,ZHANG Lei,ZHOU Fengyun,CHENG Xiaoguang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.15953/j.ctta.2024.086
2024-01-01
Abstract:Objective:In this study,we aimed to compare the accuracies and efficiencies of dual-layer spectral computed tomography(CT),quantitative CT(QCT),and dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry(DXA)in diagnosing osteoporosis.Methods:From January to October,2023,30 outpatients,including 15 males(age(56.6±8.31)years old)and 15 females(age(65.13±7.16)years old),at the spine surgery department of Beijing Jishuitan Hospital were retrospectively analyzed.All patients underwent bilayer spectral CT,QCT,and DXA of the lumbar spine.Additionally,bone mineral density(BMD)values for the L1~L3 vertebral bodies and areal BMD values were measured using DXA.Based on the diagnostic criteria for osteoporosis using lumbar spine QCT and DXA,the study participants were divided into three groups:normal bone mass,abnormal/low bone mass,and osteoporosis groups.Accuracies of dual-energy spectral CT,QCT,and DXA for BMD measurements to diagnose osteoporosis were compared using Fisher's exact test.Moreover,sensitivity and specificity of dual-energy spectral CT to measure volumetric BMD values for osteoporosis diagnosis were calculated using receiver operating characteristic curves.Results:A strong correlation was observed among the average BMD values for L1~L3 measured using all three methods(0.751~0.971).Accuracies of osteoporosis diagnosis using dual-energy spectral CT,QCT,and DXA were 66.7%(10/15),53.3%(8/15),and 40%(6/15),respectively,in males and 93.3%(14/15),86.7%(13/15),and 60%(9/15),respectively,in females,with statistically significant differences.Dual-energy spectral CT showed area under the curve values of 0.995(sensitivity:88.9%;specificity:90.5%)and 0.784(sensitivity:60%;specificity:93.3%)with QCT and DXA as reference standards,respectively,for osteoporosis diagnosis.Conclusion:Volumetric BMD values measured using dual-energy spectral CT were comparable to those measured using QCT for osteoporosis diagnosis,and both outperformed DXA in terms of diagnostic efficiency.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?