Rationalizing Catalytic Performances of Mo/W-(Oxy)Carbides for Hydrodeoxygenation

Raghavendra Meena,Guanna Li,Koen Marcus Draijer,Bastiaan M van Dam,Han Zuilhof,Johannes Hendrik Bitter
DOI: https://doi.org/10.26434/chemrxiv-2024-jr8cp
2024-11-05
Abstract:Hydrodeoxygenation (HDO) reactions are among the most important reactions for the valorization of biomass to value-added chemicals. Transition metal carbides (TMCs) are promising alternative HDO catalysts to platinum group metals. However, it is known that these TMCs have the tendency to partially oxidize themselves in the presence of oxygen or oxygen-containing compounds, which makes it a challenge to identify the nature of the true active site under relevant reaction conditions. In this paper, first, we analyze the surface structure of transition metal oxycarbides (TMOCs), i.e., Mo2COx and W2COx. Further, taking the HDO of n-butyric acid to n-butane with hydrogen as an example, we rationalize the differences in HDO performances of TMOCs as compared to TMCs (Mo2C and W2C) using density functional theory, ab initio molecular dynamics, and microkinetic modelling. It is found that the O* domains on the surface of TMOCs enhance the HDO activity by easing the dissociation of the C-O bond and promoting the hydrogenation reactions, as compared to pure TMCs. Furthermore, microkinetic modelling analysis shows that Mo2COx is a more active and selective catalyst for alkane production compared to Mo2C, W2C, and W2COx. These insights could guide the manipulation of efficient carbide-based HDO catalysts for biomass conversion.
Chemistry
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem this paper attempts to address is the exploration of the catalytic performance differences between transition metal carbides (TMCs) and their oxycarbides (TMOCs) in the hydrodeoxygenation (HDO) reaction of biomass-derived feedstocks. Specifically, the researchers aim to analyze the impact of surface structure on catalytic activity and selectivity through methods such as density functional theory (DFT), ab initio molecular dynamics (AIMD), and microkinetic modeling (MKM), particularly investigating how O* domains enhance the HDO activity of TMOCs and the performance of these catalysts under actual reaction conditions. ### Summary of Main Issues: 1. **Catalytic Performance Differences**: Researchers aim to understand why TMOCs (such as Mo2COx and W2COx) exhibit higher activity and selectivity in HDO reactions compared to pure TMCs (such as Mo2C and W2C). 2. **Impact of Surface Structure**: By analyzing how O* domains on TMOCs surfaces influence C-O bond cleavage and hydrogenation reactions, thereby enhancing HDO activity. 3. **Reaction Mechanism**: Detailed study of the HDO reaction mechanism from n-butyric acid to n-butane, identifying key intermediates and rate-determining steps, as well as the activity and selectivity differences of various catalysts. 4. **Optimization of Catalyst Design**: Based on the above analysis, propose methods to improve TMCs catalysts to achieve higher HDO activity and selectivity. ### Background Information: - **Importance of HDO Reaction**: The HDO reaction is a key step in converting biomass into high-value chemicals, particularly in removing oxygen content from biomass. - **Limitations of Existing Catalysts**: Although platinum group metals (PGMs) have good catalytic performance, they are costly and limited in resources, necessitating the search for efficient and inexpensive alternative catalysts. - **Potential of TMCs**: TMCs (such as Mo2C and W2C) have been proven to be effective alternatives to PGMs, but they tend to partially oxidize in oxygen-containing environments, forming TMOCs, complicating the identification of true active sites. ### Research Methods: - **DFT Calculations**: Used to calculate reaction energies and activation barriers. - **AIMD Simulations**: Used to assess the dynamic behavior of catalyst surfaces under reaction conditions. - **MKM Modeling**: Used to analyze macroscopic reaction kinetics, including surface coverage, apparent activation energy, selectivity, etc. ### Main Findings: - **Role of O* Domains**: O* domains on TMOCs surfaces significantly enhance HDO activity by promoting C-O bond cleavage and hydrogenation reactions. - **Selectivity Differences**: Mo2COx and W2COx exhibit higher alkane selectivity, while pure TMCs tend to produce unsaturated hydrocarbons. - **Optimal Catalyst**: Mo2COx is identified as the most active and selective catalyst, followed by W2COx. These findings provide important theoretical foundations and experimental guidance for designing efficient carbide-based HDO catalysts.